Guest Post by Anthony Sanders
The CBOE Skew index, a measure of tail risk for the S&P 500 index, just exploded.
It is now at the highest level on record.
It looks like an S&P 500 index downturn follows the SKEW breaching the 140 level.
This is not surprising given how much air has been pumped into asset markets like the S&P 500 index.
Like the mayor in the film Jaws, Fed Chair Janet Yellen and her compadre Stanley Fischer will tell everyone that it is safe to go swimming in the stock market.
Stock Share Risk Measure Rises To Highest Ever: What Time Is the Next Black Swan?
by Jesse
I did want to take a moment to try and put this skew reading in a better context for the average reader.
As you can see from the chart below the spikes in skew are more of an ‘early warning’ indicator with several steps in the two prior instances of crashes, associated with the tech bubble in orange and the housing bubble in red. I imagine history will find a similarly snappy name for our current bubble which is encompassed in light green.
I wish to stress that there is no simple linear relationship, ie a spike in skew is followed by a crash within six months, with any certainty. In other words, seeing this spike in skew and then selling all your stocks and going short the market with triple leveraged ETFs is probably not a good idea and is not likely to be fruitful, timing and market decays being what they are.
The spike in skew is more of an indication of trouble, of a stress and fear in the system perceived by some of the more sophisticated in the market who presumably also have superior access to information.
I do believe that in the two prior cases here the continuing rally of SP 500 index after a spike in skew was at least partially a result of the ‘Greenspan put’ and the ‘Bernanke put’.
That is, in reaction to fear and instability in the equity markets, the Fed modified its policy actions that had the effect of supporting the extension of what were at heart a mispricing of risk attributable to credit bubbles. The Fed is not the only actor in this. The regulators and the custodians of the public trust are very much involved in these sorts of macro mistakes.
What made this even more damaging was that, particularly in the latter case, these bubbles were wrapped around a core of extensive control frauds and intentionally mismanaged perceptions of risk, with quite a few enablers both on the Street and within the media and the regulatory bodies, either passively or actively.
I am not saying that all the motives of all the actors were malevolent. But some were.
The notion that the market is infallible is rank romantic nonsense because it will always be within the domain of human action, and is therefore a product of human nature and subject to monopoly and manipulation without the conscious efforts of ‘referees.’
N’en déplaise à ces fous nommés sages de Grèce,
En ce monde il n’est point de parfaite sagesse;
Tous les hommes sont fous, et malgré tous leurs soîns
Ne diffèrent entre eux que du plus ou du moins.
In spite of every sage whom Greece can show,
Unerring wisdom never dwelt below;
Folly in all of every age we see,
The only difference lies in the degree.
Nicolas Boileau-Despréaux, from Mackay’s Madness of Crowds
And I fear that as so often in the past, though ‘this may be madness, there may also be a method in it.’
I would take this spike in skew as more of an indicator of a probability. Notice that the skew spiked earlier in this latest phase, and then dropped as the market continued to rally higher.
There is nothing to say that this will not happen again. Why? Because there are a number of exogenous variables at play in any major market movement to say the least, as noted above in the policy actions of the Fed for example. As Walter Bagehot observed, ‘life is a school of probabilities.’
I can easily feature a plaintive response from the economists, ‘well what are we supposed to do?’
Reform the market. Get it back to a more stable and less fragile and conductive construction as we had in the 60 or so years following the reforms of the New Deal, which were overturned with the active involvement of so many economists, politicians, and Fed members in the 1990s.
But until that happens I am afraid we will see a series of bubbles and crashes, what I and others have called ‘bubble-nomics.’
It is not the ‘new normal.’ It is an aberration that seeks to sustain itself as the status quo. It is a miscarriage of justice, as old as Babylon and as evil as sin.
It does seem to be a reasonable bet that the ruling classes, existing as they do in an echo chamber of their own illusions, will do nothing to change this without exterior motivation, or compulsion.
It will be an interesting race to see which market blows up first, the stock market or the precious metals markets. Today Denver Dave asks if there is a scandal brewing in the paper gold and silver market. I would say again, and as I am sure that Dave and others have said and would agree, that there is a high probability, based on some easily observed factual data, of a serious scandal, so much so that it is merely a question of when that particular pot boils over if nothing changes.
And it may be diverting to observe the increasingly obtuse actions that the plutocrats and their bureaucracy may take to ‘save the system.’ Or perhaps, at long last, one small crash will serve as the catalyst for many in a grand bonfire of the vanities.
So in sum, as I seem to have to say so often lately, ‘timely caution is advised.’
Reform the Market – HA, HA, HA; a large asteroid will impact earth before that occurs.
Prediction – Yellen will institute another QE (whatever name they apply) before the end of the year. We may even see negative interest rate, but that would be largely ineffective until cash is outlawed (as I would only maintain a sufficient balance in my checking account and withdraw my savings account).
With all their manipulations and lies they have managed show that there is no inflation, and thus no COAL for SS recipients. And then they will increase Medicare Part B premiums by up to 50%.
Well fuck me running!
“For just the third time in 40 years, millions of Social Security recipients, disabled veterans and federal retirees can expect no increase in benefits next year, which is unwelcome news for more than one-fifth of the nation’s population.
They can blame low gas prices. By law, the annual cost-of-living adjustment, or COLA, is based on a government measure of inflation, which is being dragged down by lower prices at the pump.
The government is scheduled to announce the COLA — or lack of one — on Thursday, when it releases the Consumer Price Index for September. Inflation has been so low this year that economists say there is little chance the September numbers will produce a benefit increase for next year.
Prices actually have dropped from a year ago, according to the inflation measure used for the COLA.
“It’s a very high probability that it will be zero,” said economist Polina Vlasenko, a research fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research. “Other prices — other than energy — would have to jump. It would have to be a very sizable increase that would be visible, and I don’t think that’s happened”
“More bad news: The lack of a COLA means that older people could face higher health care costs.
Most have their Medicare Part B premiums for outpatient care deducted directly from their Social Security payments, and the annual cost-of-living increase is usually enough to cover any rise in premiums. When that doesn’t happen, a long-standing federal “hold harmless” law protects the majority of beneficiaries from having their Social Security payments reduced.
But that leaves about 30 percent of Medicare beneficiaries on the hook for a premium increase that otherwise would be spread among all. Those who would pay the higher premiums include 2.8 million new beneficiaries, 1.6 million whose premiums aren’t deducted from their Social Security payments, and 3.1 million people with higher incomes.”
so basically a market that is manipulated by a Privately owned central bank is something that I should consider when making my investment decisions? k Ive been warned and hmmm refuse to participate in said manipulated market !! if they can create the currency supply ummmm they can destroy it also , might be something to consider
@gm, did you eat something tasty when you typed that comment? The “hmmmm” and “ummmm” have me wondering…
No, that can’t be it at all. All of my friends insisted its just a correction guys, you are just being worry warts!
Sheesh.
uummmm @ riseup well actually I havnt eaten yet , but the aroma from the oven is killing me at the moment , I have 18 acres and grow chickens , when its time umm a couple of them are processed and slow cooked lol marinated in beer I actually made also lol and even tho I quit drinking ummm well since I make beer ahhh that didn’t work out so well actually . so if TSHTF im good with beer and chickens lol along with some varied veggies and legumes etc not quite self sufficient at all but dammit trying my ass off to be at least a little prepared for eventualities lol
currently working on a crop of popcorn cause im sure it will be entertaining or interesting as the Chinese would say ))) Whats that they say bout a country boy?