You can’t argue with a report that blames Greenspan, Bernanke, Congress, Wall Street bankers, the credit ratings scumbags, Bush, Paulson and Geithner for the meltdown of our financial system. I find it interesting that the Republicans on the committee all dissented. That really bodes well for our financial system now that they are back in charge. I guess Republicans think we have been too tough on Wall Street.
Financial Crisis Was Avoidable, Inquiry Finds
The commission’s report finds fault with two Fed chairmen: Alan Greenspan, right, a skeptic of regulation who led the central bank as the housing bubble expanded, and his successor, Ben S. Bernanke, who did not foresee the crisis but then played a crucial role in the response to it.
By SEWELL CHAN
WASHINGTON — The 2008 financial crisis was an “avoidable” disaster caused by widespread failures in government regulation, corporate mismanagement and heedless risk-taking by Wall Street, according to the conclusions of a federal inquiry.
“The greatest tragedy would be to accept the refrain that no one could have seen this coming and thus nothing could have been done,” the panel wrote in the report’s conclusions, which were read by The New York Times. “If we accept this notion, it will happen again.”
While the panel, the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, accuses several financial institutions of greed, ineptitude or both, some of its gravest conclusions concern government failings, with embarrassing implications for both parties. But the panel was itself divided along partisan lines, which could blunt the impact of its findings.
Many of the conclusions have been widely described, but the synthesis of interviews, documents and testimony, along with its government imprimatur, give the report — to be released on Thursday as a 576-page book — a conclusive sweep and authority.
The commission held 19 days of hearings and interviews with more than 700 witnesses; it has pledged to release a trove of transcripts and other raw material online.
Of the 10 commission members, the six appointed by Democrats endorsed the final report. Three Republican members have prepared a dissent focusing on a narrower set of causes; a fourth Republican, Peter J. Wallison, has his own dissent, calling policies to promote homeownership the major culprit. The panel was hobbled repeatedly by internal divisions and staff turnover.
The majority report finds fault with two Fed chairmen: Alan Greenspan, who led the central bank as the housing bubble expanded, and his successor, Ben S. Bernanke, who did not foresee the crisis but played a crucial role in the response. It criticizes Mr. Greenspan for advocating deregulation and cites a “pivotal failure to stem the flow of toxic mortgages” under his leadership as a “prime example” of negligence.
It also criticizes the Bush administration’s “inconsistent response” to the crisis — allowing Lehman Brothers to collapse in September 2008 after earlier bailing out another bank, Bear Stearns, with Fed help — as having “added to the uncertainty and panic in the financial markets.”
Like Mr. Bernanke, Mr. Bush’s Treasury secretary, Henry M. Paulson Jr., predicted in 2007 — wrongly, it turned out — that the subprime collapse would be contained, the report notes.
Democrats also come under fire. The decision in 2000 to shield the exotic financial instruments known as over-the-counter derivatives from regulation, made during the last year of President Bill Clinton’s term, is called “a key turning point in the march toward the financial crisis.”
Timothy F. Geithner, who was president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York during the crisis and is now the Treasury secretary, was not unscathed; the report finds that the New York Fed missed signs of trouble at Citigroup and Lehman, though it did not have the main responsibility for overseeing them.
Former and current officials named in the report, as well as financial institutions, declined Tuesday to comment before the report was released.
The report could reignite debate over the influence of Wall Street; it says regulators “lacked the political will” to scrutinize and hold accountable the institutions they were supposed to oversee. The financial industry spent $2.7 billion on lobbying from 1999 to 2008, while individuals and committees affiliated with it made more than $1 billion in campaign contributions.
The report does knock down — at least partly — several early theories for the financial crisis. It says the low interest rates brought about by the Fed after the 2001 recession; Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the mortgage finance giants; and the “aggressive homeownership goals” set by the government as part of a “philosophy of opportunity” were not major culprits.
On the other hand, the report is harsh on regulators. It finds that the Securities and Exchange Commission failed to require big banks to hold more capital to cushion potential losses and halt risky practices, and that the Fed “neglected its mission.”
It says the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which regulates some banks, and the Office of Thrift Supervision, which oversees savings and loans, blocked states from curbing abuses because they were “caught up in turf wars.”
“The crisis was the result of human action and inaction, not of Mother Nature or computer models gone haywire,” the report states. “The captains of finance and the public stewards of our financial system ignored warnings and failed to question, understand and manage evolving risks within a system essential to the well-being of the American public. Theirs was a big miss, not a stumble.”
The report’s implications may be felt more in the political realm than in public policy. The Dodd-Frank law overhauling the regulation of Wall Street, signed in July, took as its premise the same regulatory deficiencies cited by the commission. But the report is sure to be a factor in the debate over the future of Fannie and Freddie, which have been run by the government since 2008.
Though the report documents questionable practices by mortgage lenders and careless betting by banks, one striking finding is its portrayal of incompetence.
It quotes Citigroup executives conceding that they paid little attention to mortgage-related risks. Executives at the American International Group were found to have been blind to its $79 billion exposure to credit-default swaps, a kind of insurance that was sold to investors seeking protection against a drop in the value of securities backed by home loans. At Merrill Lynch, managers were surprised when seemingly secure mortgage investments suddenly suffered huge losses.
By one measure, for about every $40 in assets, the nation’s five largest investment banks had only $1 in capital to cover losses, meaning that a 3 percent drop in asset values could have wiped out the firm. The banks hid their excessive leverage using derivatives, off-balance-sheet entities and other devices, the report found. The speculative binge was abetted by a giant “shadow banking system” in which the banks relied heavily on short-term debt.
“When the housing and mortgage markets cratered, the lack of transparency, the extraordinary debt loads, the short-term loans and the risky assets all came home to roost,” the report found. “What resulted was panic. We had reaped what we had sown.”
The report, which was heavily shaped by the commission’s chairman, Phil Angelides, is dotted with literary flourishes. It calls credit-rating agencies “cogs in the wheel of financial destruction.” Paraphrasing Shakespeare’s Caesar, it states, “The fault lies not in the stars, but in us.”
Of the banks that bought, created, packaged and sold trillions of dollars in mortgage-related securities, it says: “Like Icarus, they never feared flying ever closer to the sun.”









Opinionated Bloviator says:
Maybe the coming economic collapse will force a rethink. If not the civil wars and pogroms against Congress will… or not.
Like or Dislike:
3
0
25th January 2011 at 3:09 am
Kill Bill says:
BS, They saw the financial implosion coming,
Like or Dislike:
2
1
25th January 2011 at 5:53 am
Kill Bill says:
Greed is a fuck you kind of sickness that allows its hosts to parade around in mansions at your expense.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
7
1
25th January 2011 at 6:16 am
MuckAbout says:
I suspect that the report that makes up this post is not entirely honest.
Considering how many people, hedge funds and such that saw it coming and bet against the MBS trade by shorting everything they could get their hands on, I expect the real background of this is a minimum of three times as bad as they’ve reported.
I have come to the conclusion that many, many people in this country (much less overseas where they get the straight unvarnished truth) now plainly see how dishonest and downright crooked the Federal and State Governments are along with most of the Agencies contained within.
That bolsters a “Why should I be honest and honorable when all those bastards are raping me with both hands?” This more than contributes to the moral hazard that exists today in what used to be the U.S.A. . The more dishonesty and cupidity that J6P finally understands, feels helpless to do any about, the more the moral fibre of the country deteriorates.
I’m really glad I’ve lived through the best of it (as bad as some of it has been) and hope to be long gone when the carrion eaters come home to roost and openly feast on the corpse of this country.
Like or Dislike:
3
1
25th January 2011 at 11:52 am
MuckAbout says:
Just as a comment to show that Washington isn’t the only crap-eating, crooked, rotten place on earth, consider the following.
This past November, the general voting public of Florida finally woke up to the damning dishonesty of gerrymandering. They voted to put it in the Florida Constitution that political districts must be drawn based on geographic (i.e. honest) principals instead of on the basis of race and political party.
Since January 1, when our bright shiny new Republican Governor Rick Scott was installed in office, he secretly and silently put a stop to the process of adding such an amendment to the Florida Constitution and several Florida State House politicos have introduced legislation that would nullify the 67% vote of the public to restore honesty in political districts.
The Florida State House in Tallahassee makes the U.S.Congress look like boy scouts. Whenever they go into session, you must lock up your wives and children, hide your wallet and carry a small bucket around with you to puke in now and then when they attempt to (and sometimes do) pass legislation that is just enough to make one deathly ill.
Starting this year, before Scott and the Florida legislature is finished, there will be no environmental studies before pumping sewage into a spring head, no planning on the local level allowed – the “State will take care of you” – and Florida will finish slipping down the last 100 feet of alligator mudslide crush the last ‘gator still living down there. The rest of Florida’s natural beauty will die a smokey, greasy, overpopulated death. R.I.P.
Like or Dislike:
2
1
25th January 2011 at 12:07 pm