You may have read the weekly reports showing the Chinese economy slowing rapidly and the real estate market collapsing. You may also have been wondering why the Chinese stock market has soared 60% in the last six months if the economy is going in the tank. Well look no further. Buying stocks on margin has increased by 900% in the last six months. See, the 60% increase is based on sound fundamentals. What could possibly go wrong?
China’s Stock Bubble Leaves BNP Speechless: “What Happens Next Is An Unknown-Unknown”
Submitted by Tyler Durden on 03/26/2015 20:00 -0400
Earlier this month, we identified the reason why Chinese stocks have continued to rise in the face of overwhelming evidence that the country’s economy is decelerating quickly. While the first part of the 8-month run can be plausibly attributed to PSL, the furious buying that began in late November looks to be at least partly attributable to the fact that thanks to tighter regulations on lending outside the traditional banking system, China’s $2 trillion shadow banking complex needed somewhere to put cash to work and that somewhere turns out to be the giant bubble that is the SHCOMP. Here’s more:
Because according to Reuters, it is precisely China’s trust firms, with total assets of $2.2 trillion, and who together with Banker Acceptances comprise the bulk of China’s shadow banking pipeline, and no longer able (or willing) to lend to China’s small companies and individuals due to a spike in regulation, are shifting more cash into frothy capital markets and over-the-counter (OTC) instruments instead of loans.
In other words, instead of using their vast cash hoard of over $2 trillion to re-lend and stimulate China’s economy, China’s unregulated, shadow banking conduits are now directly buying stocks!
Shortly thereafter we highlighted the 7 main reasons for the Chinese stock ramp all of which boil down to one thing: liquidity. Here they are, courtesy of UBS:
With no significant change in China’s macro or corporate fundamentals, the visible rebound in China’s A-share market since November appears to have been largely liquidity driven. We think this, in turn, may have been fuelled by a number of factors including:
1. new funds flowing into the stock market from household saving, real estate, commodities and trust markets;
2. banks’ bridge loans provided to investors who lost access to other high-yield shadow banking products as the result of tighter regulation;
3. the PBC’s easing of liquidity conditions via a variety of “targeted easing” tools (e.g. MSL, PSL, etc.);
4. the official launch of Mutual Market Access (MMA) between the Hong Kong and Shanghai exchanges;
5. long-term expectations for SOE reform and A-shares entering the MSCI index next June;
6. increased use of leverage by retail investors via margin trading; and
7. market sentiment being boosted by expectations for further policy easing.
Meanwhile, February’s RRR cut failed to meaningfully lower China’s interbank rates, likely due to continued sizable capital outflows and significant liquidity withdrawals from China’s money markets by recent IPO applications.
Meanwhile, China’s securities regulator warned investors that not wanting to miss out on the next leg up is not a good investment strategy to follow, especially in a market as frothy as this one. Now, BNP is out with a note calling China’s equity bubble “a microcosm for the overall economy: unsustainable growth in leverage masking ever-deteriorating fundamentals and increasing future downside risks.” Here’s more:
Against all odds, the best performing asset class on the planet over the last nine months or so has been Chinese equities…
…it’s not the economy (as we’ve been saying for months)…
What underlies these extraordinary gains? It is certainly not economic fundamentals. Led by the accelerating real estate slump (China: It’s Only Just Begun), China’s GDP growth has steadily slowed with reported 2014 GDP growth of 7.4% the slowest in almost twenty years. A range of ‘hard’ economic indicators such as electricity production and rail cargo volumes suggest even slower growth. Our preferred ‘real, real’ GDP estimate flags that output growth could have been as low as c.4½% in 2014 (China: Fit as a Fiddle). While the usual data fog around the Lunar New Year partially clouds analysis, high frequency indicators that generate early estimates of GDP growth suggest that the growth has continued to slide in 2015Q1…
…it must be liquidity….
By definition therefore equities’ stellar performance has been a function of liquidity driven multiple expansion. The P/E ratios for the Shanghai and Shenzhen markets have roughly doubled since August to c.19x and c.44x respectively. While still a long way short of the incredible highs of 70-80x reached during the 2006-2007 bubble, multiples are now rapidly approaching their post-GFC highs. One obvious source of fresh liquidity which could have powered equities’ bull-run is from the long-delayed introduction of the Hong KongShanghai ‘stock connect’ last November. The scheme, formerly known as ‘the through train’, allows two trading between the Shanghai A-share market and the Hang Seng. Two-way flows however have been relatively meagre. An initial aggregate quota of RMB300bn was set for northbound flows into Shanghai. So far only about a cumulative RMB125bn has flowed north, leaving RMB175bn of the aggregate quota unfilled. And northbound buy orders have in turn typically only accounted for around ¾% of the Shanghai market’s daily turnover…
…and it comes from a predictable place, leverage…
Far from a surge in external liquidity, an increasingly self-feeding domestic frenzy fuelled by leverage appears to be the key driver….Margin purchases have been running well ahead of redemptions ensuring that the outstanding stock of margin debt has ballooned by over RMB1 trillion since August; equivalent to more than 1% of GDP…
…and castles built on quicksand (i.e. margin debt) will likely collapse…
Margin purchases are now accounting for almost 20% of equities daily turnover which itself has soared to wholly unprecedented levels in another sign of self-feeding speculative frenzy. What happens next is clearly an ‘unknown-unknown’. By definition detached from fundamentals, speculative bubbles are inherently re-enforcing in the short-term and frequently last longer than expected. The longer they continue, however, the larger the eventual bursting.
China stocks may be in serious bubble
By Laura He
Published: Mar 26, 2015 11:45 p.m. ET
As market volumes explode, even teenagers are buying
HONG KONG (MarketWatch) — Some say that when the average “mom-and-pop” retail investors get back into the stock market, it could be time to get out. But what about when even teenagers start buying?
China has entered a new stock frenzy, like something out of America in the Roaring 20s or the dottiest days of the dot-com bubble, with trading volumes continuing to push to new record highs.
On Wednesday, combined trading on the Shanghai and Shenzhen markets hit 1.24 trillion yuan ($198 billion), the seventh straight session in which turnover surpassed the 1 trillion yuan mark. By comparison, the New York Stock Exchange typically saw $40 billion-$50 billion a day in trading during the first two months of this year.
The Shanghai Composite Index SHCOMP, +0.24% is hovering near its seven-year closing high of 3,691, hit on Tuesday when the index completed a 10-session winning streak.
For the year so far, the benchmark is up 13.8%, making it the best-performing major East Asian stock index of 2015 to date, though it still has a way to go to match 2014’s 53% surge.
The lure of flush times on the Shanghai market is sweeping in unlikely investors by the hundreds of thousands. This week, both the China Securities Daily and the Beijing Morning Post had dueling reports about recent college graduates and, yes, teenagers buying shares.
“Risk-Love (equity sentiment) in China’s equity market is in euphoria territory. It is time to book some profits.” Bank of America Merrill Lynch
Typically these young investors speculate with money given to them by their parents, according to a Great Wall Securities broker quoted in the Beijing Morning Post story.
Yet another report, this time by the Beijing News newspaper, relates that at the Beijing trading halls of China Securities Co., “even the cleaning lady” has opened an account to play the market.
The data appear to agree with the anecdotes: Within the last week alone, 1.14 million stock accounts were opened in China, the biggest such surge since June 2007, according to China Securities Depository & Clearing Corp.
What does it all mean?
In a note this week entitled “The Worrying Sense of Calm in China,” analysts at Bank of America Merrill Lynch got right to the point: “Risk-Love (equity sentiment) in China’s equity market is in euphoria territory. It is time to book some profits.”
After holding an overweight rating on Chinese shares since August of last year, Merrill Lynch is now cutting the market to neutral, making it clear that economic problems — especially looming deflation — suggest the current environment doesn’t justify buying into stocks.
“China’s real interest rates remain too high, the currency is too expensive, fiscal policy is tight, and debt deflation is taking hold,” the analysts said.
“We are now concerned that the scale of monetary/fiscal easing required in China is so large, and so radically different from where policy makers’ assessments are, that an overweight [rating] is no longer tenable,” they said.
But of course, there are some bulls in the analyst community as well. Erwin Sanft, a China strategist with Australian investment bank Macquarie, says that despite the recent upsurge, valuations for Shanghai’s yuan-denominated stocks are still “normal … [and] not at a bubble level.”
Speaking at a panel with financial journalists Wednesday in Hong Kong, Sanft said the climb in Chinese stocks is partly due to the fact that the Shanghai market has been moving off of an extremely low base over the past 10 to 20 years.
According to FactSet data, the Shanghai Composite’s milestones tell a story of Octobers: The benchmark turned 1,000 in October 1996, then peaked at just above 6,000 in October 2007, before crashing to a post-crisis low of 1,665 in October 2008. On Thursday, the index closed at 3,682.
Macquarie China economist Larry Hu, speaking at the same event, said Chinese stocks still have room to grow, if only because the country is in the process of reforming and developing its equity markets as a channel for companies to raise funds directly. Currently, Chinese companies mainly source funds through indirect means, such as commercial-bank loans.
Hu also said Chinese shares are benefiting from trouble in other asset classes. Trust products have turned risky amid the weakening economy, and the real-estate market is in decline, so stocks now look more attractive to Chinese households, he said.
No way! They’re the next reserve currency! Solution: Control+P.