Oh, So You Think Exponents Don’t Matter?

Guest Post by Karl Denninger

For roughly 75 years — since WWII — our “governing masters” — whether they be Fed officials, elected politicians or otherwise have run this general line of crap that indefinite forward expansion is not only possible, it’s likely and good.

As I pointed out in Leverage, and have made a lot of noise in regard to both before and since, that’s a lie.  It’s a knowing, provable lie, which can be easily demonstrated using nothing more than basic mathematics.

You see, this rock we live on has fixed size, mass and resource.  It is very large, and its resources are vast, but neither is infinite and yet that’s the requirement for indefinite forward compound expansion to be possible.

-----------------------------------------------------
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal

-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)

We therefore argue not over whether such a paradigm is possible, but merely over when the failure to do so will be recognized, and who will recognize it first.  Will it be recognized because some material subset of the population figures it out and decides to stop participating, or will it be recognized by hitting the wall on a societal basis resulting in the deaths of billions?

Then there are the secondary issues, such as will those who promoted this lie be held to account and, if so, how?  Will it through some sort of civil process, or will it be much less lawful and much more-violent?  Most-likely will be some combination; there will be places where civility will remain and due process respected, and then there will be places where it will not.

There are many charlatans who think they can argue for this or that means of evasion — becoming an expat, for example, or hiding in a hobbit hole somewhere.

But I argue that among some reasonable subset of the population, at least in the United States and a number of other developed countries, recognition has already come — quietly — to very substantial subsets of the people.

Fertility rates in the United States are at all-time lows. There will be those who argue that this is just a continuation of a trend; as people become more economically successful they have fewer babies.  But there’s something very interesting happening in this regard — women and families aren’t just postponing having kids, they’re skipping it altogether.

See, there’s a basic problem that people in the so-called “ruling classes” fail to discuss, although they all know it’s true: Debt pyramids, like all pyramid schemes, only work so long as there are always more new suckers to come along and take the reins from those before them.

We’re running out of suckers in two forms — first, women are choosing not to have kids.  And second, some not-immaterial percentage of young people, along with some older ones, are deciding they are not going to pay debts accumulated by others who you wish to throw off on them.  They didn’t vote for it, they didn’t agree to it and they see no benefit from it either.

They’re simply not going to do it and they have and will continue to find legal ways to evade the millstone you wish to toss around their necks.  They’ll cut their incomes willingly, they’ll live closer to the land, they’ll make do with less, they’ll enjoy life more and put up with less of your ****.

There’s not really anything you can do about that, by the way.  Without an ever increasing number of people willing to go after the six-figure (or more) salaries — not just a small percentage but an ever-increasing number — the pyramid eventually collapses.

Illinois is seeing a piece of this right now.  But if you think this is confined to Illinois, or even that it’s a “state-level” problem in general you’re dead wrong.

Remember that the claim has been that “animal spirits”, infused by Trump’s win in November, has spurred economic activity.  Well, if it has then why hasn’t that shown up in tax liability and thus receipts by the Treasury because it is a fact that said alleged “activity” has not occurred.

In fact, including April, which of course means including April 15th, receipts are up by a paltry 0.74%.

Tax receipts over a period of a constant tax rate structure are the most-accurate means of measuring total economic activity.  It’s not complicated folks; nobody likes paying taxes, but nobody likes going to jail either and nobody pays taxes on economic activity that didn’t happen.

Meanwhile we have two other numbers to contend with: The working age population over the last 12 months has expanded by 0.63%.  This means that adjusted for population there has been almost-exactly zero expansion in the economy over the last 12 months as represented by tax rates normed for the number of persons who can pay.

Meanwhile, during the last fiscal year the Federal Government increased debt by an astonishing $1.422 trillion, or roughly $5,500 per working-age person.  (Unfortunately you can’t compare against the current year because we’re currently under a debt freeze; when and if that is lifted things should get interesting in that regard — quickly.)

This is on top of the medical insurance premiums you paid, the taxes you paid and more.  That debt is a check written against your future earnings, in short, but the government cannot compel you to make those earnings and thus cannot compel the tax receipts that must be generated to prevent a death spiral in debt service payments.

It looks like the people are figuring that out — at least at the margin — because despite the claims of various media (cough-CNBS-cough-cough!) in terms of alleged GDP “growth rates” it is simply not being reflected in taxes paid which means the claims of a “healthy economy” are almost-certainly wrong.

Or maybe — just maybe — they’re not “simply” wrong, they’re something materially worse.

They’re LIES.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
11 Comments
Dutchman
Dutchman
July 5, 2017 2:16 pm

I predict that within the next year, the extinction asteroid will strike the Yellowstone Caldera.

End of discussion.

rhs jr
rhs jr
July 5, 2017 2:31 pm

I think God was considering it during the Hussein Administration and now we need Donald to have an Epiphany.

Diogenes
Diogenes
July 5, 2017 3:50 pm

The only numbers they are looking at is the circle jerk know as the stock markets. Once they have all jerked each other off, the game is over.
Yours in Kali,
Diogenes

kokoda - the most deplorable
kokoda - the most deplorable
July 5, 2017 4:48 pm

Repent, The End is Near.
Repent, you sinners.

nkit
nkit
  kokoda - the most deplorable
July 5, 2017 5:12 pm

I’m all repented out….

Llpoh
Llpoh
July 5, 2017 8:19 pm

I predict Illinois will experience a mass exodus of productive citizens and companies to, say, Texas, due to the stupid tax increases.

Vodka
Vodka
  Llpoh
July 5, 2017 8:41 pm

It has absolutely been the aim of Chicago to exodus people for the last 30 years. Unfortunately, for the rest of us, it was the niggers.

That has been the strategy of Chi-Town since the mid 80’s. Exodus the niggers. It’s a relief-valve for them. Some towns in neighboring States offer $200 and a one-way bus ticket back to Chicago to get rid of them. They get few takers. Most any place is better than Chicago.

A true fact.

james the deplorable wanderer
james the deplorable wanderer
July 5, 2017 8:50 pm

“Will it be recognized because some material subset of the population figures it out and decides to stop participating, or will it be recognized by hitting the wall on a societal basis resulting in the deaths of billions?”
I’m voting for the wall; politicians are too stupid to understand this (See, Illinois).
“Then there are the secondary issues, such as will those who promoted this lie be held to account and, if so, how? Will it through some sort of civil process, or will it be much less lawful and much more-violent? ”
What makes you think it will be limited in any fashion? Once the Crunch hits and the currency collapses, SNAP and EBT cards fail and store shelves are emptied, widespread hunger will drive widespread hate and desperation crime. An uneaten sandwich may become justification for murder; even cannibalism may make a comeback. EVERYONE who survives will have the killer instinct AND THE MEANS to carry it out; we will become vicious victors or victims.
Lack of imagination on MY part does not prevent barbarity on OTHER’S part. I will try as hard as humanly possible to save and preserve me and mine; there will be no guarantees.
Those who survive will get the job of rebuilding.

Hondo
Hondo
July 5, 2017 11:04 pm

Well it looks as if the aborted babies will have the last laugh after all. While they are watching from the balconies of heaven the people who murdered them will be crushed when the pyramid collapses. Poetic justice. Two other things to comment on here about the ridiculous stupidity engulfing america (I don’t capitalize it anymore). Number one, in florida a guy killed a nuisance cat with a crossbow and then erased the security video. The cops called in the Secret Service Electronic Crimes Agency of america to recover the erased data. The guy, by the way with no previous criminal record, has been arrested, and could face up to twenty years in prison for doing the world a favor and then erasing the tape. We have thousands upon thousands of missing people, unsolved murders, gangs tormenting the neighborhoods, and a damn sixteen year old war we can’t win, just to name a few, and to ad insult to injury, law enforcement personnel are worried about a stinking cat. So all you fine leather belt wearing, hamburger eating animal lovers have a good day. Personally I hope you rot in hell where you belong, and the sooner the better. Number two, if possible look up the Victoria Advocate online and see what our grand and glorious Sheriff had to say this morning. It should come as no surprise that he wants more money, because he had to dispatch all of his deputies to one, yes just one, domestic dispute involving just one man and one woman, and this left him without any other deputies to patrol the rest of the county or to respond to the people’s needs. What a fucking mess. So, you might want to give a second thought before moving to Texas. Are there any adults left out there?

Econman
Econman
July 6, 2017 2:32 am

I’ve seen articles where prosecutors were trying to justify people paying hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines or getting 10+ years in jail for pirating movies or downloading songs.

As an econ teacher, it always makes me laugh when socialists/leftists and some communists try to persuade me their system works. Not only is history not on their side, neither is math. You need a vibrant capitalist society whereby people are generating CAPITAL, creating businesses, being productive in order to generate tax revenue. I always ask them, “Where are you going to get the money?” Usually blank stares, or “Tax the rich!”, “Tax the greedy corporations!”, … The majority of these people are government workers (more like non-workers) or, the trendy thing, work for “non-profits”. I also notice they are the worst business people I meet. No clue on how to run a business because they don’t understand “evil” capitalism.

Morons.