What if? Why not?
Guest post by Robert Gore at Straight Line Logic
Scott Adams, creator of the Dilbert comic strip, has a phrase—mental prisons—for looking and thinking at problems in the same old way. He’s hailed President Trump and Kanye West as escapees. That’s fine as far as it goes, but key to any kind of general escape is recognizing that governments are the wardens.
Hospital administrators and doctors within Britain’s National Health Service (NHS) were little Alfie Evans’ wardens. They determined the 17-month old’s brain condition was terminal and he was in an irreversible vegetative state, and ordered his life support withdrawn. Alfie’s parents, Tom Evans and Kate James, contested the prognosis and the order. That they had to go to a court for permission to seek alternative medical arrangements tells you all you need to know about state-provided medical care. That permission was denied offers a sneak peek into Britain’s impending totalitarianism. Alfie died April 28.
Never underestimate the power of questions, they are the most powerful positive force in the universe. Questions embody curiosity, courage, and a quest for the truth. They initiate investigation, hypotheses, experimentation, new knowledge, and progress. The first questions humanity’s forebears asked began the long, arduous journey to civilization.
MAGA was the Trump acronym; his symbol should have been the question mark. The two are related. The acronym implies America is no longer great, which prompts the obvious question: Why? The source of most of the vitriol directed toward Trump is not so much his answers, which have often been contradicted by his actions. Trump’s transgression is that he dared to question in the first place: immigration policy, foreign military intervention, trade agreements, costs of alliances, corruption, and so on.
Government creates a comfortable status quo for government, string pullers, and beneficiaries. Its prime imperative is to preserve itself. Any change perceived as a threat will be resisted, stifled, and squelched. Questions are inherently threatening, so Trump must be stopped at all costs. Tom Evans and Kate James must not be allowed to challenge their son’s death sentence. Kanye West must be shamed and ostracized.
A deadly deception sells government with terms like “progressive” and “liberal.” Governments are coercion, which is always regressive and illiberal. They are captured by a society’s wealthiest and most powerful and used to cement that group’s status. Crumbs are tossed to the lower rungs, not to improve their station but to make them dependent on the government and ensure their support. Criticism of this arrangement is tolerated only to the extent it can’t be suppressed, but suppression always looms, sometimes blatantly, sometimes in barely perceptible ways.
Scott Adams and other commentators see Kanye West as the start of something dramatically new among blacks. Doing electoral math, some foresee an appreciable downshift in blacks’ usual 90 percent plus support for Democrats, which will, they claim, doom the donkeys. Such triumphalism is misplaced.
It’s not like Kanye West is the first black to question black fealty to Democrats. Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams have been skewering shibboleths on race for decades.
Indian-American Dinesh D’Souza’s documentary Hillary’s America examined the Democrats’ long history of overt racism. It’s support of slavery, the Klu Klux Klan, Jim Crow, poll taxes, and segregation, and its opposition to anti-lynching and civil and voting rights legislation made the racist south a solidly Democratic bastion for almost a century. Blacks voted overwhelmingly Republican for seventy years after the Civil War.
Franklin D. Roosevelt switched them to the Democratic column. The impetus was primarily economic and political, not civil rights. The New Deal helped those most devastated by the Depression, many of whom were black. Politically, Roosevelt offered them a place in the Democratic coalition, although it put them in uneasy alliance with the southern racists. The switch offers insight into blacks unwavering support for Democrats since Roosevelt.
Years ago, The Wall Street Journal’s editorial board started referring to the Democratic “plantation” for blacks, and the phrase is still in use, usually by conservative commentators who regard it as a bold badge of political incorrectness. Blacks ignore it and the implicit question: when will they “wake up,” realize their slavery, and flee the plantation? If they’re receiving economic and political benefits from Democrats and governments, paid for in part by taxes coerced from The Wall Street Journal’s editors and conservative commentators, who’s the slaves?
While racism may never be excised entirely, blacks’ legal status and their position vis-a-vis America’s governments have never been better. Many receive substantial economic largesse from the government, including cash, in-kind benefits, and preferences in hiring and contracting. Blacks, almost always Democrats, have been elected to just about every political office in the land, including the presidency. Multi-millionaire West doesn’t need government, but millions of blacks do, and they vote for the party that identifies itself as the party of government.
One can argue that black dependence on the Democrats and government is bad for them; dependence of any kind usually is. Everyone knows overeating can kill you, but we still have an obesity epidemic. Black dependence is a shackle, but it’s durable and won’t be unlocked just because a rich rap star questions it.
Presidents have found shackles easier to break when they don’t involve domestic constituencies. Nixon went to China and Trump is going to the Korean peninsula to negotiate with Kim Jong-Un. While the outcome is uncertain, if Trump eventually gets an agreement by which North Korea denuclearizes, perhaps in exchange for the US withdrawing troops from South Korea—or at least stopping war exercises—and security guarantees from the US and China, it will be a triumph. Moon Jae-in, Kim Jong-Un, and Trump will deserve the Nobel Peace Prize.
Trump asked what if the stalemated status quo that had held sway on the Korean peninsula since the cessation of hostilities in 1953 could be broken. The usual establishment and media suspects said their nays (see “Media Pundits Horrified by Prospect Between North and South Korea”) but had only the usual palaver when Trump asked why not. It’s a measure of how bizarrely ossified their thinking has become that a peace and nuclear disarmament initiative is mocked, lambasted, and rejected out of hand before negotiations have even begun.
Trump is also questioning the status quo on Iran, pulling the US out of the Iranian Nuclear Agreement. Evidently he wants to negotiate a better deal. The move is thoroughly questionable: his strategy has a lot of moving parts and he’s taking significant risks. Time will tell if things work out, but once again Trump is indisputably disrupting the consensus.
The welfare and warfare state consensus should be questioned and disrupted at every turn. The empire and its bread and circuses have corrupted and bankrupted the nation. Government is an intellectual tar pit that slows, traps, and submerges curiosity and inquiry. Questions are the hallmark of free minds. The state is the natural enemy of free thought. A fight for the latter is a fight against the former. Questions will spark the coming battle. They are weapons of independence and revolution which governments can never wholly suppress. Were they ever to do so, we’d all share Alfie Evans’ fate: hitched to their life support until they decided to kill us.
“Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams have been skewering shibboleths on race for decades.” Sowell and Williams have sold everybody out, but particularly their own race. The idea of skewering black dependence and simultaneously cheerleading the offshoring of dignified blue collar employment that has crushed the American black family is total bullshit. There’s a whole generation of sellouts that needs to disappear courtesy of Father Time. We will be a better country for it. I doubt Kanye is going to sell out the same way Sowell and Williams did.
Detroit auto management and unions did a great job of killing blue collar jobs, too. As did Johnson’s “Great Society.” Then the host of discriminatory legislation passed to benefit blacks did a job on race relations. The “drug war” coupled with welfare that paid black women to have more kids without husbands made sure that black kids grew up poor while being constantly enticed by the money in the drug game. And on and on.
It’s socialism that crushed the American black family. It’s voters who got behind it. I see Williams and Sowell as two who tried to point out the disastrous effects of socialism on blacks. I admit that I don’t know anything about this “cheerleading” you speak of. Seems odd that they would do that.
Try to explain this, Bigfoot. Niggas didn’t gangbang when they were making $35 an hour building Chevrolets. When they shipped those jobs overseas, something Sowell and Williams were enthusiastic supporters of, what took its place? The socialism you speak of. When traitors like Sowell and Williams point out socialism as the cause, they are skipping the actual cause, the economic devastation of those people who once were self-supporting, going to work everyday. Sowell and Williams are what are called Magic Negros. Many people, especially conservatives, love to hear anything come out of the mouth of a black person that parallels their own belief system. Those two crooks have made a career out of selling out not only the country, but as I say above, their own race, just by spouting corporatist talking points. I’ve seen Thomas Sowell interviewed on Charlie Rose many times, his dodge when asked a tough question, is always to answer with another question. He ain’t that bright. And he certainly doesn’t have any answers to anything. Total Uncle Tom. Bought and sold traitor to his country and his race.
Maybe you can point me to where Sowell and Williams enthusiastically supported the export of jobs? Very hard to understand why they would do that.
But those two did not cause voters to put in office the likes of Johnson, Carter, Bush, and all the rest of the socialists in Congress over many years. But if those columnists did as you say I for certain don’t blame you for your condemning them.
Starfcker,
I don’t know Sowell’s and William’s position on every issue, but I’d be surprised if I agree with them all because I don’t agree with anyone 100 percent. However, both gentlemen have written numerous articles, and in Sowell’s case books, that have explored and exploded many myths concerning race and ethnicity in this country and elsewhere.
I’m more familiar with Sowell’s work so I’ll talk about him. It’s hard to see how he was selling out his race when he was one of the first to empirically document that labor unions and government, pre-Civil Rights legislation, discriminated against blacks far more than private businesses and to explain the reason why (the costs of irrational discrimination to labor union and government decisions makers are far lower than to private business decision makers).
Sowell has frequently argued that much legislation, including minimum wage and welfare laws, ostensible sold as ways to “help” blacks have only hurt them. He always offers an abundance of evidence to support his arguments. He came up the hard way and has little sympathy for many of the excuses proferred for black underperformance relative to other groups.
He has always demonstrated a prickly independence and is most definitely nobody’s “Magic Negro.” That comment is simply offensive and wrong. So too is calling him an Uncle Tom, as that term is wrongly understood. (Uncle Tom in Harriett Beacher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin was a profile in courage, see my review on SLL, “The Best Novel Nobody Has Read, https://straightlinelogic.com/reviews/fiction/the-best-novel-nobody-has-read/.)
Sowell has certainly demonstrated far more intelligence and courage throughout his career than Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, Eric Holder, Barack Obama, and their ilk. That his positions often find favor with whites, especially conservatives, in no way makes him an Uncle Tom. If would have been far easier for him to join the race hustlers and bask in the approval of white liberals. He has endured much vitriol and abuse from liberal blacks and whites and has never flinched.
The assertion I disagree with most vehemently is that Sowell “ain’t that bright.” I had him for a labor economics class at UCLA and he was brilliant. It was one of the most stimulating classes I’ve ever taken. He easily makes the top three most intelligent professors I had as either an undergraduate or graduate student. If all you’re going on is Charlie Rose interviews, I suggest you read one of his many books.
Robert, well said sir.
Robert, I own several of his books. I once held him in high regard. Here’s where I broke with him, and virtually every other conservative huckster. When you are a shill for globalism, which is essentially the destruction of the existing economic system, it’s really hard to tolerate somebody chastising people who were once self-sufficient becoming needy. The system he was promoting is what caused the neediness in the first place. Every society has to have a mechanism for distributing the means to get the things life requires, and there are only two. A system where people work and are compensated for their honest work, and socialism. When you destroy the first, the second is inevitable. Jim ran an article by Jordan Peterson a couple weeks back, let me find it and link it.
I think Peterson’s point of view is far more valid and more socially desirable in any of the crap coming out of Sowell’s pie hole. Take a glance, particularly number 6. Citizens have an inalienable right to benefit from their own honest labor. That’s a building block of society right there. That disappeared the moment Clinton signed NAFTA. And that’s exactly why Donald Trump is President and exactly what he’s looking to turn the tide of. Without fixing that, the rest of the stuff, welfare, etc., is just nibbling around the edges. Trump is going straight for the globalist jugular. There’s nothing wrong with globalism, but at the expense of the general welfare of the United States, there is nothing desirable about it. We never voted for it. So we are going to be ruled by corporate multinationals, or, are we going to be a democratic republic, take your pick. I like our current position a lot more than I like anything in Europe. Lack of guns is looking like a real Achilles heel for those people
Starfcker,
I don’t disagree with your premise: “Every society has to have a mechanism for distributing the means to get the things life requires, and there are only two. A system where people work and are compensated for their honest work, and socialism.” I do, however, disagree with your timeline and consequently, cause and effect.
Socialism got its foot well through the door during the New Deal and World War II, when the US ran gigantic trade surpluses and its manufacturing was second to none. To the extent the term globalism was even used, it meant US domination of a world virtually destroyed by the war. When Johnson launched the Great Society and later, when Nixon followed on with his welfare state measures, adding to Roosevelt’s New Deal, the US still ran a trade surplus (it turned to a deficit in 1976), and black unemployment and illegitimacy rates were only marginally higher than those of whites. I submit that Roosevelt, Johnson and Nixon’s enactments were far more responsible for turning, “people who were once self-sufficient becoming needy” than globalism. I would add a steady ratcheting up of the minimum wage, pricing young blacks out of the labor market, must share the blame.
I am unfamiliar with Sowell or Williams acting as shills for globalism. If you’ll point me in the right direction, I’ll look into those writings, and perhaps comment further.
That ain’t hard to do. After all, promoting globalism is what those two are paid to do. Here’s Williams. http://www.rockymounttelegram.com/Columnists/2018/03/14/Trump-s-Steel-and-Aluminum-Tariffs.html And follow that up with a short piece from never Trumper Sowell. The guy is dumb as a rock. https://youtu.be/EmxhfHCZ-jI. Can you find an original thought in either piece? Or could they just be reading a script written by Larry Summers?
Meanwhile, starfcker thinks Elon Musk is a genius. Now that’s funny.
Starfcker hitting the bottle again.
I’m sure, from many of us here, we thank you for pointing out the many ignorant and offensive statements by “Starfcker”
The big difference between them and Kanye, however, is that Kanye is much more famous, especially with the younger generation of black men…So he is much more of a threat to the Establishment.
star….just an addition:
The welfare state had a lot to do with crushing the black family – due to the regulations, provisions in welfare laws offered ever-increasing economic incentives for shunning marriage and avoiding the formation of two-parent families, illegitimacy rates rose dramatically.
Sowell and Williams both bought Tesla’s.
Betchya like them now, eh?
On a side note, that rant above is even more delusional than your pro Tesla rants. Are you off your meds again?
How about, you blow me. But I would look favorably upon them driving Teslas, since they are made in America
Plus they can keep you warm on a cold winter night when they explode into a ball of fire.
Thanks!
One of the best of your acute observations:
“Never underestimate the power of questions, they are the most powerful positive force in the universe. Questions embody curiosity, courage, and a quest for the truth. They initiate investigation, hypotheses, experimentation, new knowledge, and progress. The first questions humanity’s forebears asked began the long, arduous journey to civilization.”
Began, yes. However, we are nowhere even remotely close to civilization, and have never been. I suppose that we are sort of fumbling our way towards it, by trying to find everything that doesn’t work. When the last of the nation states has burned to the ground, then we will at least have an actual chance of reaching civilization. It will still not be guaranteed, but on our current trajectory, it IS guaranteed that we shall never find it.
No, nation states with their own traditions ARE civilization.
Phyrrus with the best post of the day
The American people are getting tired of being patted on the head and told “Move on, there’s nothing to see here.” The jig is up, so to speak. How this turns out is what we are living through right now. I don’t foresee the questions diminishing, only growing louder and more demanding. This is a great thing.
I don’t think the jig is up for most people yet. They are still dancing to it. Because that is what they want to do.
M C
Trump is not a politician. Trump is not in the WH to do politician things. He’s a citizen. He’s there to do citizen things like make the fuckin’ country better for citizens. He’s going to level the playing field for the world so that wars of choice are no longer the eternal threat and hinderance to peace and cooperation.
Q’s asking tons of questions and citizens are digging up tons of answers. Enjoy the show.
I downvoted you for your ‘chicken in every pot’ attitude. You said Trump “is going to level the playing field for the world so that wars of choice are no longer the eternal threat and hindrance to peace and cooperation” ????????????
Suppose you are right about ‘leveling the playing field’, so that would mean that he will bring the rest of the world’s standard of living up to the level enjoyed here in the USA? Or, if you are right about the ‘wars of choice are no longer the eternal threat to hindrance of peace and cooperation’…would that be right after the war he is aiding Israel to execute in Syria? Just as soon as his Sec. of Commerce, Wilbur Ross (a Jesuit trained Rothschild Invest. banker) procures the oil rights for Rothschild owned Genie Energy ?
Trump is a freemason fraud, just like Obammy before him, and Bush before him, and Clinton before him…..and on and on! Just overlook how Soros money helped him build the skyscraper in Chicago, or how Rothschild money baled him out in the late 80’s and early 90’s ?
‘Indentured Servants’ when we were born, and we’ll be indentured servants when we die !
annuit coeptis novus ordo seclorum…..and King Trump will be the savior and ruler of the world !!
Pray
The caste with rent of land and title broadcast the dream for the owners into the workers. Of course that is a lie, but there are dreams and kids to feed.
Modern enlightened cognition seems to be the order of the day.
Expensive and gets a lot killed. With benefits.
I might have gone another way.
What is this – fucken haiku day?
A convincing and cogently compelling column.
I suspect when their bellies are no longer full.
Regarding Trump: What if he is a demolition man? Would that be a good thing or a bad thing? How will we know?
Insofar as I think the whole system has to be torn down, I hope he is a demolition man and I think it would be a good thing.
Good article Robert. Yes, question EVERYTHING. I’ve been a maverick my whole life, never doing anything the easy way but still being successful. I don’t know how the whole system gets torn down without some major black swan or multiple black swans. I see us slowly circling the drain into a Venezuela style melt down. We’ll know that die is cast if there are no prosecutions or other MAJOR swamp draining actions over the next two years. The Federal Government is a lawless dictatorial behemoth that is strangling our freedoms and is unresponsive to the people it supposedly represents. Local governments at city, county, and state levels are no better. The layers of government over us, our individual liberties, and freedoms is like a wet blanket smothering everything we would try to accomplish. That’s a lot to tear down. I don’t see how it happens. Again, great post… Chip
Chip
“I’ve been a maverick my whole life, never doing anything the easy way but still being successful.”
It’s precisely because you’ve been a maverick who’s never done anything the easy way that you have been successful.
Thank you.
The question IS the answer.
Robert,
Such a wonderful article you have written!
Thomas Sowell has made a questionable remark or two, but his
body of work is about economics, and he shines.
President Trump? He is the Great Disrupter, and I am grateful he
is exposing the fraud our governments indulge in left and right.
People want instant results! Prez. is supposed to wave a wand, and
magically erase decades and layers of players’ frauds…and march them
into GTMO? (we would need multiple GTMOs)
I am familiar with the concept of spring cleaning. One starts with dusting
the ceilings and ends with scrubbing the floors. There are many layers
in between those two steps. Does this analogy work? Men may scoff.
Let us be grateful that people are listening, doing research, figuring
things out for themselves. Further, the concept of “prepping” has gone
mainstream. Change is a process, not a declaration.
Suzanna
Thank you for your excellent comment. Your spring cleaning analogy is spot on.
“Never underestimate the power of questions, they are the most powerful positive force in the universe.” ——-article
That’s why I do Stucky QOTD.
However, I don’t think questions are the “most powerful positive force in the universe.”. That would be the undying faith Trump-eteer’s have in their Lord and Savior, Donald Trump.
Vote down you bitchezz!!!!
” ….. Kanye West as the start of something dramatically new among blacks. ” —– article
Give me a break. You are either hopelessly delusional, or eternally optimistic.
One Famous Kneegrow isn’t going to change THE MINDSET of millions of gimme-free-shit I-dindu-nuffin useless eaters. Yes, there are blacks who don’t buy into the Dems-gots-our-backs bullshit. You can find several on the internet, youtube, etc. such as Diamond&Silk and others. But, they are a minority, and you know it. Personally, I think 90% of kneegrows will remain Dem slaves into the foreseeable future.
That is, unless something DRASTICALLY MONUMENTAL happens. Because that’s what is absolutely required for people to change their ways of thinking … thinking (if you can call it that) that has captured their minds for over 100 years. One rapping kneegrow ain’t gonna change shit.
I was saving this for a potential May transitions piece, but according to a Reuters poll taken after Kanye West posted a picture on Twitter wearing a MAGA hat – support for Trump among black men doubled in one week.
From the link —– “it should be noted that Reuters only sampled slightly under 200 black males each week and slightly under 3,000 people overall.”
Teeny tiny sample size. meh
Not to mention that I’m now generally negative on polls. They are too easily manipulated. And I trust no one anymore. Remember …. right up to election day the polls said Hillcunt would CRUSH Donald.
Yeah. And, even with that, the doubling was only from 11% to 22%. One still wonders, though, if such a small sampling MIGHT be indicative of a larger trend? If so, then it COULD have possible ramifications in the midterms by way of a black ripple dampening, somewhat, the “blue wave”?
If not, then you will be proven correct in saying “one rapping kneegrow ain’t gonna change shit”; and I wouldn’t be surprised at all if your assessment is proven true.
However, advertising does work. If it didn’t, then companies like Nike and Pepsi would not pay millions to black athletes like Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods to promote flashy footwear and artificially sweetened and colored carbonated water.
With Trump’s schtick and panache, coin, and conquest of caucasian cuties, he may be a better sell to that demographic than bathhouse Barry ever was?
Just trying not to underestimate the power of questions over here.
I live in a town that is 46% black. As such, I overhear a lot of conversations … especially in the library and at my barber (who is also black). I’m not seeing any Republican love.
Anecdotal I know, plus I live in Libtardville … but, still ….
When I was in high school, we had one visit our town. It was on its way to Chicago. It had curly hair and it looked a lot like the ones you saw on TV. It didn’t smile when I went up to it and said “dynoMITE!”
-For your consideration, Stucky:
You are the world. Change yourself and you change the world. – Jiddu Krishnamurti
There is nothing more difficult to take in hand or more perilous to conduct…than to take the lead in the introduction of a new order of things. – Niccolo Machiavelli
Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has. – Margaret Mead (this one is kind of iffy, but it’s often quoted)
As water judges a swimmer’s rightness in swimming, God judges a man’s rightness in living. – Rose Wilder Lane
In other words, do what is right. You might change the world or you might not, but doing what is right is living without goals, which often as not interfere with doing what is right as when the goal becomes more important than the work itself. To focus on a goal, the end point, instead of right action is to reach for the ideal, which can never exist except in thought. Every kind of evil has come out of the reach for ideals, every kind of goodness has been sacrificed in the name of ideals.
We might be happy a little to see a famous black man speak from his heart whether that leads to something or not. In any case it is a good thing and not something to disparage and belittle because it may not and is unlikely to change the world.
And for laughs:
Change will not come if we wait for some other person, or if we wait for some other time. We are the ones we’ve been waiting for. We are the change that we seek. – Barack Obama
Wrong.
“All political power comes from the barrel of a rifle”. Anything less is just words.
Bob..
Government is an intellectual TAR PIT. You never cease to amaze me with those explosive one liners.
You should compile them like a Farr Side calendar.
It would probably sell better than my books do (not a high bar).