There is an extraordinary case out of British Columbia where a father referenced as CD was arrested after he continued to refer to his biological 14-year-old daughter (known as AB) as “she” and his “daughter” after he transitioned to a male gender. The Supreme Court of British Columbia, Canada ordered that the child receive testosterone injections without obtaining parental consent. CD opposed the transition as the parent but he was overruled after physicians at BC Children’s Hospital who decided the girl should receive testosterone injections. The father continued to defy gag orders, including a bar on his trying to persuade with his own child to wait before making such a change.
We have previously discussed how such pronoun disputes (called “misgendering“) lead to criminal investigation in other countries like Great Britain.
The Canadian courts withheld the father’s name but he has since gone public in interview and has a GoFundMe site under his real name.
Previously, in a 2019 decision, Justice Gregory Bowden rejected the parent’s view as largely immaterial:
In view of the established law regarding the right of a mature minor to consent to medical treatment and the assessments of a number of physicians that A.B.has capacity to consent as well as the evidence of his health care providers that the proposed treatment is in A.B.’s best interests, there is no serious question to be tried.
At the second stage of the RJR test, the inquiry is whether the litigant who seeks the interlocutory injunction would, unless the injunction is granted, suffer irreparable harm. A.B.’s father has not demonstrated that a refusal to grant the injunction would adversely affect or irreparably harm him.
After that decision, there was a gag order put into place that barred the father from even trying to convince his son to change his mind:
“[1] AB, a 14 year old transgender boy, applies for a protection order to restrain his father, CD, from publishing, speaking or giving interviews about this case or about AB’s personal and medical information.
“a) CD shall be restrained from: i. attempting to persuade AB to abandon treatment for gender dysphoria; ii. addressing AB by his birth name; and iii. referring to AB as a girl or with female pronouns whether to AB directly or to third parties;
“b) CD shall not directly, or indirectly through an agent or third party, publish or share information or documentation relating to AB’s sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, mental or physical health, medical status or therapies.”
The evening of the Bowden’s decision, CD spoke to the Federalist and said “because she is a girl. Her DNA will not change through all these experiments that they do.” He added:
“I had a perfectly healthy child a year ago, and that perfectly healthy child has been altered and destroyed for absolutely no good reason. She can never go back to being a girl in the healthy body that she should have had. She’s going to forever have a lower voice. She’ll forever have to shave because of facial hair. She won’t be able to have children… Sometimes I just want to scream so that other parents and people will… jump in, understand what’s going on. There’s a child—and not only mine, but in my case, my child out there having her life ruined.”
That led to a conviction of the father for “family violence” in April 2019. Furthermore, Judge Francesca Marzari even issued an order authorizing Clark’s arrest “without warrant” by any police officer who might catch him referring to his daughter “as a girl or with female pronouns.”
Later YouTube interviews with the father were removed. In addressing one of those interviews, Justice Michael Tammen of the British Columbia Supreme Court even ordered that Laura-Lynn Thompson to pull her interview and, when she did not, he sent police to her house.
The decisions reject any substantive weight given parental rights. I have long opposed an absolutist position against parental rights in areas like abortion with minors. The use of criminal penalties against this father only magnify those concerns.
I personally disagree with the father in the use of the pronoun if his son has made this choice. I would yield to the child’s preference. However, the question is whether the state should play such a coercive and intrusive role in a family.
Ordering a parent not to speak to his child about the issue or arresting him for referring to the child’s biological gender raises very serious parental and free speech rights in my view. I realize that many experts believe that opposing such gender transition is abusive and harmful. I do not discount that view. However, that is a position best left to persuasive rather than coercive means. We can debate this question and many can oppose the use of such pronouns as abusive.
Yet, arresting a parent for continuing to oppose such a transition or referring to the wrong pronoun is chilling. There is an utter disregard of the countervailing interests and rights of parents in these decisions.
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal
-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)
Waiting to read about the pope’s position on this matter.
That’s a tough one to figure out.
Frankie will like it; y’know , for being so “progressive”.
He approves because he thinks the T in LGBTQ… stands for “trinity.”
And yet……I am laughed at when I try and tell people. “Everything is collapsing right in front of us”
It is getting difficult being right in the world today as lies and deceit are the order of the day.
What a heartbreaking story for the father.
What psychos in the school supported, pushed for and aided a 13 yo to destroy her life?
And when she/he commits suicide, as so many do, where will the courts and psychos who supported this insanity be? What responsibility for this fiasco will they be accountable for?
Society has protected kids from their inability to make intelligent, informed choices involving life changing events.
Ok courts, give her a driver’s license, UBI and HE can get shitfaced and celebrate at a bar with the fellas. Why not?
You agree that he should have used her chosen pronouns? Another sheep catering to perverted narratives.
Chaos is the goal.
We’re workin’ on it.
Sure hope the Republicans can win big in 2022!
Remember to squint a little when voting. It makes it so the communists can’t change your vote.
You forgot your sarc tag.
“I’m sorry, Dave. I’m afraid I can’t do that. This mission is too important for me to allow you to jeopardize it.”
–DOMINION HAL 9000
You’d yield to the child’s choice? What would you say that the role of a parent actually is?
I’d say the real question is, what kind of medical establishment would even agree to participate in such a travesty as this? Doing irreparable, horrible harm to a child. It’s sickening.
People refusing to call reality what it is and stand up to this crap is how we got this to begin with.
BC’s Childrens Hospital. The hospital thats ‘supposed’ to treat children. They do plenty of great work but massively screwed up by promoting this BS.
To the person who personally disagrees with the father: May u join these bastardos in hell. And the sooner the better.
We all ought to fall on our knees and beg God to rain down fire and brimstone on North America.
A Sweet Meteor of Death is what we need. The target should be that courthouse. Preferably when that Judge is sitting on bench. Prayers to Lord Odin to make it happen with the added request that whole event is broadcast live on CBC.
This is ‘Dr’. Wallace Wong. He/it is responsible for this child having puberty blockers and being turned into a freak. Wong and the ‘judges’ that rule against the father and promote the grotesque monstrosities cavorting in human form who are fine with having a young girl take puberty blockers to essentially become a neuter.
The queer agenda is alive and well, the perverts are in charge, the inmates run the asylum and the ‘woke’ liberals all believe it is fine and dandy to sexualize children, to mutilate children all in the name of being progressive and ‘tolerant.’
Justice Francesca Marzeti is an avowed ‘social justice warrior’ pushing social justice causes, as are all the other leftist judges involved in this case. These are the ‘enlightened’ jurists, they consider themselves progressive and open to the new and enlightened way of reforming society and relieving it of such silly notions of family and paternity and protecting children from deviancy and sexual abuse.
The new and enlightened social justice warriors believe that children should be sexualized and exposed to every manner of deviancy, that they shouldn’t be forced to engage in sexual stereotyping, but rather, that children should be allowed to become whatever their teachers and social justice arbiters determine is best for them.
https://historyproject.allard.ubc.ca/law-history-project/profile/honourable-madam-justice-francesca-v-marzari
Under communism children are the property of the State and they can do with them as they please. The family is not tolerated because its completely contrary to the States objectives. Parents roles are to feed the children, nothing more.
Here in canukistan the courts have been overtaken by the communists a LOOOONG time ago. This isn’t really a surprise. The courts just gave our medical political license to do whatever she wants if she ‘believes’ it beneficial. EVEN if its against the law.
I have for years i have for years, but,
Genesis 18:32
And he said, Oh let not the Lord be angry, and I will speak yet but this once: Peradventure ten shall be found there. And he said, I will not destroy it for ten’s sake.
Still too many righteous around, once it reaches a low enough percentage…
So maybe next week…
This has been allowed as society, i.e. conservatives, did not give the required pushback when this started. Now the marxists and the law are calling it a right. 50 years too late. Without a complete breakdown and restructuring of society nothing will change. Lew Rockwell has this article:
and this:
It is a from of insanity and should be treated as such. Enabling insanity is a form of insanity itself.
Much appreciated links.
Disgusting. Those responsible for destroying that poor girls life should be thrown in jail for life and the biotech companies that enable this forced to develop methods to reverse the effects
That’s way too lenient…
You know what happens to pedophiles in genpop? I believe many more prisoners were sexually abused than admit it.
I don’t agree with the evil practices conducted in prisons, which I know a little too well. But the reality is the reality. Life in prison without chance of protective custody.
One has to wonder if bill gates holds positions in those biotech companies.
Justice Gregory Bowden will be held accountable in some way. Perhaps not in this world where logic, reason, and common sense are rapidly disappearing, but certainly the next.
If the father did his job, Justice Gregory Bowden wouldn’t be making any more decisions. And the father would be facing much more serious charges. And he should be okay with that, having done what God put him on this Earth to do
Tough call. The mother is a wingnut too. Burning the judge would solve nothing. The government would still take the daughter and she’d be institutionalized, foster homed. He’d still lose everything and we’d only be down one communist.
This is the fruit of communism… coming to the USA very soon. You free trial is over.
I never said he ought to stop at the judge. Yes, he would lose everything. So what? Sometimes that’s what real men do
I’m glad that people publicize these issues, but the author of the article turns into a massive fag at the end.
There can only be absolutes when you deal with monsters who destroy children, their futures, and families. And by monsters, I mean ALL of them with any power who support it. The activists and politicians, and more so those who PROFIT from this evil – the psychiatrists, doctors, judges, and lawyers.
Agreed. Great post, Anon
Agreed that the author is a massive faggot that belongs at the bottom of a bog with the other sodomites.
This. I hold only 1 black and white opinion that I do not ever question. Due to my own experience I believe that all pedophiles, all of these who destroy children’s innocence should be killed. No mitigating circumstances, no “understanding”, none of it. Bullet to the head is more mercy than they show these children that, and make no mistake, they destroy.
There is nothing I hate more than pedophilia. I guess in this new normal I’m going to be the bigot, the unenlightened and backwards redneck. So be it. This is one subject I will not compromise on and will not apologize for. One subject that I have no understanding or good will towards these people.
I’d vote to have the judge, the docs, and the lawyers neutered and given work in a harem in Saudi Arabia.
Since when is a 14 year old a mature adult? This is satanic…Home School or die…
I am sure the judge does not consider this young girl mature enough to purchase a handgun.
Maybe if she were to use it for suicidal purposes as it mimics the original intent.
How about buy a beer?
The new term I learned in the article is ‘mature minor’.
That means all teenagers 13 to 17 are mature minors. Wow!
Legal adult begins at 18, but according to Obama, a child can be on a parent’s health care until 26.
Don’t even mention the age of consent for the mambla pervs.
It’s the same old scam. You’re always old enough to do whatever your rulers want from you, but you’re never old enough to do something you want to do yourself. We thought we fixed that with the 26th amendment. How naive we were.
Can’t buy a gun, can’t drink a beer, but can vote for all the Democrat gimme candidates multiple times in any election… and they think the age limit for that needs to be lowered.
What is a “mature minor?” Is like a major minor perhaps?
Moral questions like this are answered by going back to the words and actions of the Founders of various faiths.
When presented with a moral quandry, modern Orthodox Heemeyerists ask themselves this question:
What would Marvin Heemeyer do?
Now, obviously, followers of St. Tarrant or St. Breivik arrive at different epistemological and theological conclusions, but they are all equally valid in the eyes of the Allfather Odin.
The Courts could do nothing if there was no “Marriage Contract” where the State is the primary member of a three party Contract.
The Courts could do nothing regarding the young girl if the mother did not deliver (abandon) the young girl and sign the abandonment paper called a Birth Certificate.
It is all in the language.
We speak the language of illiterates called Dog Latin.
The Courts and the Government speak and hear the Legal “higher Latin” which is most times a different and opposite meaning.
Latin is far from a dead language.
By volunteering into the Contract with the State and using the Legal Name, we are all subject to its arbitrary whims.
We are truly destroyed by lack of knowledge.
I am right there with you caught in the same trap. I at least know now why I am in the trap.
There is some doubt Latin ever was a living language. Interesting points on the contracts.
A girl is a girl is a girl is a girl. And a boy is a boy is a boy is a boy.
Yet another reason to dismantle the government “justice” monopoly.
Although not as demented as the American prison system (almost an order of magnitude fewer prisoners), Canada’s justice system is way more dysfunctional than ordinary people realize. I sure as heck didn’t, past tense.
You have no idea… Its so far left we are getting into the N Korea/China range of disfunction.
We are so far left that even the Chinese think we are crazy.
https://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1047989.shtml
The destruction of the English speaking world is just breathtaking and astonishing in its rapidity and comprehensiveness.
The father should abandon the child at the steps of the British Communumbia legislature steps, supreme court building or at the premiers official residence with a note explaining it is their problem now.
The scum who have permitted this will find their special studio in Hell to be most accommodating.
Has nothing to do with English-speaking.
The whole Western “civilization” is collapsing.
It’s not English-speaking, or Western, but WHITE.
Homeboy should burn down that hospital and courthouse. This shit will only end with violent reaction as reason is long gone.
ZFG, out.
P.S. those fucken “doctors” ought to be curb stomped for their quackery.
I was always told that the Nazis burned books. Bad thing and I believed that the Nazis were bad for burning books. And then I found out what specifically they were burning: the transgender “research” books pushed by their academics. And I no longer though that they were as bad as I thought.
CTV (also in Canada) had a special featuring a clearly sexual deviant father who had his son transition at about the age of 11. It featured an overly cheerful talkshow host. As the little boy discussed and promoted the joys of wearing girl’s underwear, the camera panned over pictures of underwear.
The father’s crooked smile occasionally twitched. It was revolting. Also, images of his son dancing in a gay pride parade. (Really a gay self-hatred parade.) As I left the room to retch, a commercial featuring another sexually mutilated child came on.
Canada has been broken for a long time now.
Jonathan Turley: “I personally disagree with the father in the use of the pronoun if his son has made this choice.”
Thanks for letting us know your stance. You may GFY now.
Where in the fuck is the outrage from the psychiatric community about how society is enabling a mental disorder among children, allowing them to make these decisions on their own!!!!! WTF!!!
“the psychiatric community” is busy making sure everyone wears a mask because it is the only thing they know how to tell you that is healthy for you….
I wish we knew more of the story from the girl’s (now, boy) perspective.
WHY did she make this choice? Did her father have some role in this choice via the way he raised her? (No, I don’t want to blame the father … I just want to know how he raised her). Was she bullied in school? How LONG has she felt this way? Years? Or just a few weeks?
Can’t find anything on the net. If you guys do, it would be great if you posted the link …. I’m sure you’re as curious as I am.
I bet it all leads back to the mother. Probably a psycho. Mother isn’t even mentioned in the article.
There is another case going this route too. I get them confused as they both have pretty much the same outcome. One is the mother is a complete wingnut and this one is a mental illness.
Either way, the courts are doing their best to screw these families up for life the best they can.
I don’t have time to read every link I find on the interwebs…..but there are multiple if you go to utube to watch the video in the article. The first link in the description section of the video had this:
“Clark and Sarah separated in 2013. Their separation and subsequent divorce seems to have been a relatively peaceful one–their agreement involved a high level of mutual cooperation and custody time shared equally between mother and father. But Clark believes that the parental split still hit Maxine pretty hard. Not yet 10 years old at the time, Maxine began to make some poor choices of friendship at school. Her difficulties escalated as she began adolescence, and by grade six her school was frequently reporting her to her parents for misbehavior. In grade seven, at around the same time that Maxine began experimenting with her gender identity, she developed an infatuation with her first male teacher. When Maxine was forced by the school to stop writing this teacher love notes, she sunk into a period of depression and self-imposed isolation, during which she declared herself a lesbian and spent copious amounts of time secluded in her room with the lights off and the shades down, limiting her social interaction to online chat rooms.
In grade eight, while she was being affirmed in her transgender identity, Maxine had a second infatuation, this time with a male P.E. teacher. Her advances were, of course, not requited, and she was removed from that teacher’s class. Nevertheless, she continued to stalk him around school, and engaged in a suicide attempt which she attributed to being rejected by her teacher.
According to the National Post, Maxine’s mother Sarah described Maxine’s self-harm as the result of “the dysphoria” she feels with her feminine body. Nevertheless, multiple factors were likely at play.”
https://thefederalist.com/2019/02/26/doctors-insist-canadian-14-year-old-needs-no-parent-consent-trans-hormone-injections/
“the dysphoria” was a link that led to:
“Max is now at the centre of a complicated legal fight over who gets to decide the course of treatment for his gender dysphoria. Max and his mom, Sarah, with the support of the gender clinic at B.C. Children’s Hospital, want to proceed with a treatment plan that would involve injecting Max with testosterone — a key step, they say, in Max’s desire to transition from a female to a male body.”
https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/who-gets-to-decide-when-a-14-year-old-wants-to-change-gender
annuit coeptis novus ordo seclorum <—–==== it's all part of 'the plan'
You da Man!!! Thank you, ordo.
Wow. Infatuated by and stalking men as a 7th grader??! Then declaring herself a lesbian! This child has some serious problems internally, it seems.
Jeebus, when I was 12 years old I still wasn’t sure what my weenie was good for, other than taking a pee.
The school curriculum here is pooched. We were seeing what was being taught because of the grand daughters work and teacher interviews my daughter was going to. They start that shit here in BC in grade 2.
Needless to say our daughter whom we homeschooled has now taken to home schooling her daughter. And we are there helping. Its a hill to die on.
“Any man who lets his enemies educate his children is a fool.”
– Malcolm X
This and the links on Lew Rockwell are much appreciated.
I do not want to blame the father but this screams “lack of a father figure” in her life. Seriously she was looking for a father figure. No idea why this happened, maybe the father had nothing to do with it and the child was simply mentally unstable from the beginning but I know of so many fathers that leave the child rearing to their wives completely and allow the women making crazies out of normal children for the sake of peace of mind and sometimes their laziness.
None of us know what the dynamics behind this are really about. But consider, its the father thats going to jail and fighting hard for his daughter. Defying the court order that he call his daughter a son. I don’t think its the fathers fault… its mental illness, likely with a lot of help from the school system and doctors.
The B.C. governement is also criminally psychotic, isn’t it?
(With blessings and bounties from Ottawa )
May they all rot in hell (except the father and his DAUGHTER).
“Women will rule them, and children shall be their oppressors” …somewhere in the book of Isaiah.
We need to outlaw the transgender SS.
I hope you mean Social Services. But if you mean Schutzstaffel, the rare fags in their midst were shot. Himmler thought homosexuality was caused by an unnatural society and was proud about all the healthy outlets they created to allow men and women to meet.
In case you missed it, I’ll copy what Fish said above
“I was always told that the Nazis burned books. Bad thing and I believed that the Nazis were bad for burning books. And then I found out what specifically they were burning: the transgender “research” books pushed by their academics. And I no longer though that they were as bad as I thought.”
He should have been calling the judge “tool”.
The quicker Canada goes down the tubes, the more natural resources will be left for non-Canadians to exploit. Go Canada!
Let’s see if we understand this dilemma
A father CD is not allowed to invoke his parental rights for deciding the transgender changes are not in the best interest of his daughter.
The health officials are able to override parental rights and will have no responsibility for the best interests for a 14 year old.
14 yr old’s are still developing emotionally, physically and mentally.
To start pumping hormones into a child’s body sounds wrong minded and not in the best interests. These decisions should be made by developed adults not children
CD keep up the fight to keep your parental rights! .
A huge majority of these people in authority were given over to a reprobate mind….In society there are some that are still able to hide behind a façade of normalcy, but inwardly they are ravening wolves. We stand at the crossroads of good versus evil; the great falling away has begun. Some will see it but others won’t!
I suppose all of you who support this had all the answers when you were 14 years old? I know I didn’t and many CHILDREN at the age of 14 are still discovering and learning about themselves, and their bodies. I personally feel this child had been abused by the system. State-sanctioned abuse.
Agreed. But did you also think you were a man and want to chemically sterilize yourself?
Dollars to donuts in 5 years she/he will be another lost soul on the “downtown East Side” Lowest economic postal code in canada, where the open street drug market is….
Of course they did.
And in the same vein, nobody is coming to take your guns, either.