Plunging oil prices will starve the world of its economic fuel

Low prices mean no new oil, and no new oil means no growth

Getty Images
If oil prices do not recover and quickly, the U.S. shale miracle will rapidly turn into a shale bust.

The world economy is slowing down and the authorities are worried.

Besides the official gross domestic product statistics, we have further confirmation of this slowdown from the four big commodities associated with growth; oil CLF5, -3.81%   (-40% from June 2014), coal (-52% from peak in 2010), copper (-14.4% in 2014), and iron ore (-41% year-to-date 2014).

Japan, Italy, and Greece are all in recession. China is slowing down according to its official statistics, and even more according to the whispers.

The days of rapid economic growth are behind us because the days of cheap oil are behind us.

Germany, France and the Netherlands are all at stall speed.

The U.S. is, according to the Commerce Department, doing just great at nearly 4% growth, but you wouldn’t know that from either the quality of the new jobs being created (which is low) or consumer spending (also low).

The worry, as always, has nothing to do with the central banks’ concern for you, your job, your children, wealth equality, or the future, and everything to do with the simple fact that the stability of the banking system absolutely depends on a steady stream of new loans being created.

The core of the problem is that we have a monetary system that is either expanding or collapsing. It has no steady state.

In 2008 and 2009, net credit creation was only slightly negative, but that was enough to very nearly cause the entire system of money and banking in the developed world to collapse.

Either money and credit are expanding and the banks are relatively happy or the banks are collapsing and demanding taxpayer bailouts. It’s really that stark.

Now after the most heroic run of interest rates forced to zero (ZIRP) and below (NIRP in Europe) and the grandest experiment with money printing in global history, credit growth is somewhat back on track but not enough to ease the bankers’ worries.

So they continue to pump, and jawbone, and panic at every slight downturn in wildly inflated financial asset prices because those are their only major successes in this drama.

The actual economy, the one that lives on Main Street, never really recovered, at least not compared to past recoveries. Growth, jobs and incomes all were anemic compared to prior recoveries. Capital expenditures by corporations were all but dead in the water throughout the “recovery.”

If oil prices do not recover and quickly, the U.S. shale miracle will rapidly turn into a shale bust.

And this brings us to the collapse in oil prices.

Our view here at Peak Prosperity is that the days of rapid economic growth are behind us because the days of cheap oil are behind us.

Oil fuels the engine of growth and the world has spent $2.5 trillion over the past nine years chasing more oil and yet is producing roughly the same amount of oil as it was before it spent all that money.

As Jeremy Grantham put it in his latest quarterly newsletter:

“As a sign of the immediacy of this problem, we have never spent more money developing new oil supplies than we did last year (nearly $700 billion) nor, despite U.S. fracking, found less — replacing in the last 12 months only 4½ months’ worth of current production! Clearly, the writing is on the wall.”

Unless investment in oil production really accelerates from here, new production will be swamped by existing declines.

But with oil down some 40% since June, new oil drill programs are being scrapped left and right.

New drill permits in the U.S. shale plays were down 40% in November compared to October and for good reason: most of the plays are uneconomical at current prices:

The bottom line, though, is that without growth in oil supplies robust economic growth is impossible to achieve.

What Is the 2015 Economic Outlook?

If oil prices do not recover and quickly, the U.S. shale miracle will rapidly turn into a shale bust. The decline rates on these wells are ferocious. With that loss of production will go the entire narrative that says that peak oil is somewhere off in the distant future and that we can safely ignore it for now.

Worse, global oil projects are now on hold and those potential future supplies have been pushed out further waiting for higher oil prices.

No new oil means no new economic growth. It’s as simple as that.

This calls into question the sky-high valuations we currently see for stocks and bonds. The operative question being, what is the value of these stocks and bonds in a world without growth?

To me the answer is simple; a lot less than they currently are.

So the central banks are worried that their efforts to ignite new borrowing are not working, but I am worried that the bloated asset prices that were a product of this quest are going to run straight into the reality of diminished oil output.

In short, my worry is that we are now well past the point where the next financial correction can be avoided. It’s going to hurt.

The central banks have failed, perhaps honestly and with good intentions, but they have failed nonetheless. All because they were peering out just one of several portholes and thought they understood the world.

Chris Martenson is an economist and futurist who co-founded the PeakProsperity.com blog.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
7 Comments
SnowieGeorgie
SnowieGeorgie
December 8, 2014 1:12 pm

I heard on the evening news last night that SUV sales are up.

Ya gotta love it !

SnowieGeorgie

ss
ss
December 8, 2014 4:14 pm

Some who don’t think deeply about the reasons for lower oil prices automatically have a knee-jerk reaction that “lower is better”.

But some causes of lower oil prices are dangerous to our future especially higher unemployment in the US and worldwide which reduces demand for consumer and industrial oil consumption causing more job losses.

I still believe cheap oil resources are depleting fairly quickly despite fracking and suspect ROI for investors is also decreasing due to increased costs of extracting and processing other oil forms. This should help cause oil price increases but apparently unemployment and lack of demand are much higher than reported which is why oil prices keep falling.

Would it ever be made public that we are truly running out of cheap oil and the costs of keeping industrial economies going with more expensive alternatives will begin to skyrocket? Perhaps the ruling class is intentionally creating the conditions for higher unemployment to try to lessen consumption and the rate at which cheap oil is depleting?

Probably not but I wonder sometimes since cheap oil runs the world – and supplies are finite.

Welshman
Welshman
December 8, 2014 4:32 pm

I read this article a couple days ago, and think Chris Martenson is spot on. The unintended consequences just blow me away. Our gal Ogla hit it on the head this AM, we are so Fucked.

Mike
Mike
December 8, 2014 5:37 pm

If, prices keep going down, maybe GM, and other auto companies, will start selling trucks, and cars. Then hiring back factory workers The oil glut could cause, people to buy more goods from china, and we could sell all the coal we want to them and the rest of the world.

Maybe at gas at 1.50 a gallon and energy, so cheap, it would cause a manufacturing boom and more jobs, right here at home. More jobs mean more taxpayers.

All that money sitting in banks and in the market, might come out for investment, in the US economy.

But it would cause deflation, thus the bankers won’t let it happen.

So screw the economy and cheap energy, and cheap goods, and a better standard of living.

Bea Lever
Bea Lever
December 8, 2014 6:39 pm

Does anyone remember what happened to oil production back in 1986 when the USA and Saudi Arabia flooded the world with oil until the price was under $10 per barrel? The object was to financially sink the soviets and it worked. Domestic production was not a big factor if I remember correctly. As I have posted we may be seeing round two.

BP is on their own in this one.

Kill Bill
Kill Bill
December 8, 2014 7:02 pm

So the oil industry loses some jobs. Cheap fuel prices create other jobs elsewhere..more people will fly, tourism will go up. People will have more to spend on things besides high fuel costs.Those BP managers can go to Saudi for all I care.