Racket of Rackets

Guest Post by Jim Kunstler

If you thought banking in our time was a miserable racket — which it is, of course, and by “racket” I mean a criminal enterprise — then so-called health care has it beat by a country mile, with an added layer of sadism and cruelty built into its operations. Lots of people willingly sign onto mortgages and car loans they wouldn’t qualify for in an ethically sound society, but the interest rates and payments are generally spelled out on paper. They know what they’re signing on for, even if the contract is reckless and stupid on the parts of both borrower and lender. Pension funds and insurance companies foolishly bought bundled mortgage bonds of this crap concocted in the housing bubble. They did it out of greed and desperation, but a little due diligence would have clued them into the fraud being served up by the likes of Goldman Sachs.

-----------------------------------------------------
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal

-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)

Medicine is utterly opaque cost-wise, and that is the heart of the issue. Nobody in the system will say what anything costs and nobody wants to because it would break the spell that they work in an honest, legit business. There is no rational scheme for the cost of any service from one “provider” to the next or even one patient to the next. Anyway, the costs are obscenely inflated and concealed in so many deliberately deceptive coding schemes that even actuaries and professors of economics are confounded by their bills. The services are provided when the customer is under the utmost duress, often life-threatening, and the outcome even in a successful recovery from illness is financial ruin that leaves a lot of people better off dead.

It is a hostage racket, in plain English, a disgrace to the profession that has adopted it, and an insult to the nation. All the idiotic negotiations in congress around the role of insurance companies are a grand dodge to avoid acknowledging the essential racketeering of the “providers” — doctors and hospitals. We are never going to reform it in its current incarnation. For all his personality deformities, President Trump is right in saying that ObamaCare is going to implode. It is only a carbuncle on the gangrenous body of the US medical establishment. The whole system will go down with it.

The New York Times departed from its usual obsessions with Russian turpitude and transgender life last week to publish a valuable briefing on this aspect of the health care racket: Those Indecipherable Medical Bills? They’re One Reason Health Care Costs So Much by Elisabeth Rosenthal. Much of this covers ground exposed in the now famous March 4, 2013 Time Magazine cover story (it took up the whole issue): Bitter Pill: Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us, by Steven Brill. The American public and its government have been adequately informed about the gross and lawless chiseling rampant in every quarter of medicine. The system is one of engineered criminality. It is inflicting ruin on millions. It is really a wonder that the public has not stormed the hospitals with pitchforks and flaming brands to string up that gang in the parking lots high above their Beemers and Lexuses.

There are only two plausible arcs to this story. One is that the nation might face the facts and resort to the Single Payer system found in virtually every other nation that affects to be civilized. There is no other way to eliminate the deliberate racketeering. The other outcome would be the inevitable collapse of the system and its eventual re-set to a much less complex, cash-on-the-barrelhead, local clinic-based model with far less heroic high-tech interventions available for the broad public, but much more affordable basic care. Both outcomes would require jettisoning the immense overburden of administrative dross that clutters up the current model, with its absurd tug-of-war between the price-gouging hospital “Chargemaster” clerks and the sadistic insurance company monitors bent on denying treatment to their sick and hapless “customers” (hostages). Be warned: these represent tens of thousands of supposedly “good” jobs. Of course, they are “good” because they pay middle class wages, of which there are fewer and fewer elsewhere in the economy. But, they are well-paid because of the grotesquely profitable racket they serve. They’ve turned an entire generation of office workers into servants of criminal enterprise. Imagine the damage this does to the soul of our culture.

My suggestion for real reform of the medical racket looks to historical precedent:

In 1932 (before the election of FDR, by the way), the US Senate formed a commission to look into the causes of the 1929 Wall Street Crash and recommend corrections in banking regulation to obviate future episodes like it. It is known to history as the Pecora Commission, after its chief counsel Ferdinand Pecora, an assistant Manhattan DA, who performed gallantly in his role. The commission ran for two years. Its hearings led to prison terms for many bankers and ultimately to the Glass-Steagall Act of 1932, which kept banking relatively honest and stable until its nefarious repeal in 1999 under President Bill Clinton — which led rapidly to a new age of Wall Street malfeasance, still underway.

The US Senate needs to set up an equivalent of the Pecora Commission to thoroughly expose the cost racketeering in medicine, enable the prosecution of the people driving it, and propose a Single Payer remedy for flushing it away. The Department of Justice can certainly apply the RICO anti-racketeering statutes against the big health care conglomerates and their executives personally. I don’t know why it has not done so already — except for the obvious conclusion that our elected officials have been fully complicit in the medical rackets, which is surely the case of new Secretary of Health and Human Services, Tom Price, a former surgeon and congressman who trafficked in medical stocks during his years representing his suburban Atlanta district. A new commission could bypass this unprincipled clown altogether.

It is getting to the point where we have to ask ourselves if we are even capable of being a serious people anymore. Medicine is now a catastrophe every bit as pernicious as the illnesses it is supposed to treat, and a grave threat to a nation that we’re supposed to care about. What party, extant or waiting to be born, will get behind this cleanup operation?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
24 Comments
Anonymous
Anonymous
March 31, 2017 10:07 am

A call for socialized medicine (single payer system) is just calling for the same government that screwed things up to somehow be able to fix things if we just give them unlimited and ultimate power.

I have at least some degree of doubt this will work, and no doubt at all that it can never be corrected at all if it doesn’t.

Dutchman
Dutchman
  Anonymous
March 31, 2017 12:01 pm

There are so many things that are so fucked up (not just health care) – the only solution is for this whole shit wagon to go completely off the tracks.

Anonymous
Anonymous
March 31, 2017 10:07 am

I agree with everything except the insinuation Single Payer is the way out of it. This just inserts the government even more than they already are between the patient and doctor with all the setting of prices and rationing of services this brings.

prospector
prospector
March 31, 2017 10:11 am

Major causes for high medical bills:

1. lawyers, and medical malpractice insurance
2. Emergency room visits by stoopid people who enjoy waiting 5 hours for a diagnosis of either a headache or heartburn or a sprain.

the last time I was in the emergency room for a fractured wrist, I had to wait for:

Taisha and her mom, who were ahead of me, and little Taisha was jumping around on the examination table, while her mom said “you gotta sit, you may have a bad ankle that our landlord will be paying for”

no shit.

Captain Willard
Captain Willard
  prospector
March 31, 2017 11:17 am

Dear Prospector:

Lawyers and ER knuckleheads are indeed annoying. Yet this is not where most of the money gets spent. The majority of your “life cycle” health-care costs are going to occur after age 65: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1361028/

We all hate lawyers and for sure, defensive medicine adds to systemic costs. And I agree that the ER is not the most cost-effective venue for care delivery and is subject to abuse. But ER visits are 2% of total healthcare costs and obviously some are legitimate. http://newsroom.acep.org/fact_sheets?item=29928

I think the bigger problems are heroic but futile, costly end-of-life treatments and of course, chronic illnesses like diabetes. Such chronic illnesses account for massive costs to the system, both during adulthood but especially after age 65 when all the body abuse catches up with you. A lot of this problem relates to lifestyle choices and is a tough nut to crack (as Admin has written regarding the Philly soda tax).

Apropos of your ER anecdote, about 10% of ER visits are diabetes-related: https://www.hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/statbriefs/sb167.jsp. This epidemic of diabetes alone could break the US healthcare system if nothing changes. My cousin is an endocrinologist in a southern city and could tell you many funny/sad stories. He has many patients who don’t understand that carbohydrates (in biscuits, mac ‘n cheese etc.) convert to sugar in the digestive process. I shit you not!

I just lost my Dad to cancer and he/Medicare spent a fortune of money the last year of his life to no avail. His prognosis was never good and he would have suffered less going straight to hospice. Needless to say, the system would have saved a lot of money too.

If we’re serious about saving money, we have to have a mature “national conversation” about managing obesity and giving people incentives to maintain a healthy lifestyle. We also have to have serious conversations about end-of-life issues. Obviously I’m not in favor of “death panels” etc., but how do you encourage rational healthcare for terminal/poor-prognosis older patients when the families and patients have no “skin in the game”?

I agree with Kunstler, Charles Hugh Smith and other clever bloggers that healthcare is a cartel and the system is really screwed up from the provider and insurer side. But it’s also screwed up from the patient side. Less government and fewer Cheetos is a good start. And I agree, perhaps muzzling some lawyers couldn’t hurt either.

David
David
  Captain Willard
March 31, 2017 3:46 pm

If you have a disease, you take achievable steps, such as getting to and maintain a target BMI if diabetic, or else society does not have to pay. If you do not want to make the effort, why should I?

Similar to if Germany and France do not think it is worth their money to protect themselves, why should we.

rhs jr
rhs jr
March 31, 2017 10:19 am

I think Obama already drained the swamp of all the honest, patriotic and capable Americans.

starfcker
starfcker
March 31, 2017 10:27 am

Kunstler, like Denninger, writes a column about the sky being blue, and wonders why the world doesn’t aplaud his genius at figuring this out. No shit, sherlock. Like Denninger, the only solution he can see, is blow everything up. Ain’t gonna happen like that. We need to bring real industry back, and then transition all the make work types, just like the welfare types, back into productive activity.

entre nous
entre nous
March 31, 2017 10:49 am

Jim,
You need to sit down face to face with Karl Denninger and talk about the sickcare racket. Option one single (tax)payer will not work. Option two a market based system without insurance companies and governments will.

Enjoy the chat.

kokoda - the most deplorable
kokoda - the most deplorable
March 31, 2017 10:51 am

Unless CONgress/Trump change something, Nobody will be prosecuted.
The worst financial collapse in history with obvious fraud by the Banksters and nobody goes to jail. If they won’t indict the Banksters, there is no hope for the Medical Insurance industry.

Most all politicians are bought and paid for and don’t deviate from Party Leadership dictates, except for Rep. Freedom Caucus (yeah).

Anon
Anon
March 31, 2017 11:24 am

I stopped reading when I saw “single payer.” The problem with Healthcare is government, which means we need more free market and less interference by politicians (i.e., liars) and bureaucrats (i.e., people who do not produce).

NtroP
NtroP
March 31, 2017 11:59 am

Did Kunstler dine with Denninger earlier this week? Also, did you notice JHK earlier this week, in writing, converted/confessed/denied he any longer agrees or believes in the leftists?
One problem for us conservative, libertarian leaning folks is that the single payer thing does work, at least somewhat, in most of the rest of the civilized world, at least in direct comparison to the failing cartel mess we’ve put together. Note medical tourism.
No I don’t think it’s a good solution, but almost anything looks good next to the medical mess we are in.
If I have The Big One (ala Fred Sanford) I will probably just have to die, as I don’t have the $100-200K to carry on, and am probably too far from the Oklahoma Surgery Center for the $10K ambulance ride.

Capn Mike
Capn Mike
  NtroP
March 31, 2017 5:42 pm

Medical tourism is a cash business.

hardscrabble farmer
hardscrabble farmer
March 31, 2017 11:59 am

I know I am going to sound like a radical again but what if we try this- you pay for your own medical bills.

I understand that the ripple effect of shutting down insurance companies- who provide zero medical care and simply add an entire layer of costs to an already expensive segment of the economy-would have an impact, but over time those paper shufflers would find some other meaningful form of employment and the markets would recover from the loss of their sugar daddies.

It is counter intuitive to force healthy people who work to subsidize the obese and indolent who do not. If you are a smoker and you get cancer, sorry, no treatment for you. There are children who have done nothing and suffer from the same disease and need the treatment, they should be prioritized.

The entire system is predicated on multiple false premises, from the ridiculous ‘access to medical care is a fundamental human right’ to the equally ludicrous ‘bad life choices are a disease’, i.e alcoholism/drug addiction.

General
General
March 31, 2017 12:57 pm

I could write a book on the problems with healthcare. While the simplest and most cost-effective solution to healthcare is to BAN all third party payers, including Medicare, Medicaid, and all commercial payers, that is never going to happen politically. Also single payer by itself doesn’t work either, since the corrupt politicians would be in charge.

What most countries that I have been to have done is a two tiered system. The poor get their “free” crappy single payer government run system, and the wealthier citizens pay for their own efficient and better care with their own money.

Dennis Roe
Dennis Roe
March 31, 2017 12:58 pm

If you have a question about billing, please call 1 800 Wedontgiveashit. Thank you. Have a nice day.

Seabudz
Seabudz
March 31, 2017 3:03 pm

Here is an interesting plan that will get no play anywhere but it’s always nice to dream.

HEALTH FREEDOM AND HEALTH FASCISM

Nurse Ratched
Nurse Ratched
March 31, 2017 3:59 pm

My own reasons for supporting single payer are pretty self serving…recognizing that as much as it is morally and practically superior to have a free market in health care it will not happen, what are the choices? Our current situation is so perverse, so encouraging of moral hazard and waste, it is sickening at times to be a participant, despite the occasional amazing good you get to do. The sheer stupidity of having to cater to non-paying waste of space morons whose main complaints revolve around the lack of narcotics administered, poor channel selection on our cable provider, the quality of the free sandwiches, the limitations on cab vouchers, and my all-time fav, the wait time for non-emergencies in the ER (“I have waited x long, if this were a real emergency I’d have died” is said with absolutely no self awareness or irony). Under single payer, at least, that kind of b.s. would get left in the lobby to self triage right back out the door. If you don’t like our government run facility, feel free to go across town to the next government run facility. At least for the time being, we are still human, the actual emergencies will still get appropriate care. Probably more efficient in those cases, because less time will be spent on the bull crap stuff. Makes my job easier.
I’m a little bitter today, worked last night and fielded 8 overdoses, 102 angry family members, one actual stroke whose life was saved, and a hospitalist who took 4-5 hours to place admission orders, guaranteeing every admission at least a 7 hour stay in the ER (hence the angry people). Ours used to be considered to be a tidy little modestly efficient suburban hospital in a nice part of town, suitable for getting stitches or ankle xrays after falling off a ladder doing home mainenance, mostly known on the inpatient side for hip and knee replacements. In the last 10 years it has been a front row seat to the degeneration of American culture.

General
General
  Nurse Ratched
March 31, 2017 10:40 pm

Easy solution to the admission problem. Have the ER doctor write a basic set of admission orders. That’s what my hospital does.

Nurse Ratched
Nurse Ratched
  General
March 31, 2017 10:59 pm

Ah, clearly you have me confused for someone with actual power…

Alter Boyz
Alter Boyz
March 31, 2017 5:43 pm

Poor Kunstler.

It just keeps getting worse for him.

Gong.

Suzanna
Suzanna
March 31, 2017 8:28 pm

Single payer health care is available in many “civilized” countries.
And the people are civilized. Certain segments of our population
aren’t so civilized and threaten other patients and the caregivers,
literally. Who would want to work there?
These “civilized” countries have two tier systems. The expectation
that everyone be equal and be treated just the same is the poison
we have to deal with. Most of us would pay “insurance” to be in
a pool of people for catastrophic care, otherwise, I would prefer a
pay as you go system.

TampaRed
TampaRed
March 31, 2017 8:31 pm

This is how they treat borderline cases in a single payer system-be careful what you wish for.

Mother Held Her 22-Week-Old Premature Baby for an Hour Until He Died After Doctors Refused Care

TampaRed
TampaRed
April 1, 2017 2:37 pm

here you go boys,cheap insurance fron across the pond–

comment image?oh=1d490ec08a0775fe64e380e9153822ba&oe=595DCD7D