Right now, Omicron is on the way down, and politicians are peeling back mandates. Democrats — the party of restrictions— have wisely tried to distance themselves from mandates, which are rapidly becoming radioactive. A few however have made different choices.
Covid-19 cases will continue to fall, but Twitter anxiety is tied to the second derivative. That means when cases start rising more slowly, people relax, and the opposite on the other end.
Very likely Covid case counts will someday rise again. I am not in the modeling business— I prefer to be accurate— so I don’t know when, but surely at some point, they will climb. What will states do in response?
Politicians
It is a tough question. Politicians have exhausted political capital. Even if you think lockdowns work (i.e. transiently slow spread), locking the whole country down in March 2020, when many/most places did not have much spread, likely fatigued the populace and meant by Oct/Nov. many places had zero political capital to take any action. Fast forward to today, and there is simply zero appetite for this even in blue locations. I doubt any place can reinstitute business closures, even if they wanted to.
But delaying infection (outside of true health system collapse, and assuming these things even did that) stopped making sense after vaccination was widely available in the Spring of 2021. Breakthroughs will occur, but all we can do to mitigate harm is vaccination itself. The trade-off of holding society at a standstill is far more unpalatable as time goes on.
When cases rise, politicians will panic. Democrats will be in the tough spot, as they may try again to embrace these (unproven) tools. I suspect some may reach for what they know: masking and business closures, but they do so at their political peril.
Scientists
Scientists could have done better. No one knows which interventions slow spread and which do not, particularly around kids masking, or population-wide n95 use (just because it’s a better filter don’t make it a better policy), we simply don’t know how big the effect size is, or if it only works under some or not other circumstances (such as beyond some prevalence)
The way to figure these out is large, cluster RCTs, but we ran zero in the USA. For this reason people who say now is the time to stop masking, and those who say we need to start it again, are largely making things up. No one knows that it works below some prevalence or above some prevalence. And, we have no data that is reliable at all in kids.
Policy makers
The biggest challenge is for policy makers. What is the goal now? Covid-19 cannot be stopped; it will spread across all people and we are likely to be infected several times over in our lives. What is the goal then? Policy makers have never said what their goal is.
In my mind the goal is to minimize harm of the eventual spread.
This means Step 1: Document natural immunity. We have clear data now that natural immunity is very protective against future reinfection and hospitalization, so someone who has it can be left alone. Offit and others argue they can get 1 dose of vax. This is also reasonable, but they don’t need 3 doses, and we don’t have to waste political energy to force them to get 3.
Step 2: People who don’t have natural immunity, who are older or vulnerable should get 3 doses. Most healthy adults should get 2. But the biggest gains would be if we at least give 1 dose to those who have 0 doses and no natural immunity. We should pursue this vigorously.
Immunocompromised people fall into two categories. The first are folks with transient immunosuppression, such as those immediately after BMT transplant.
These folks may require aggressive efforts to protect and isolate from others (as much as possible) until they recover. They also need 4 doses and maybe also evushield. The second category is permanent immunosuppression. These people may also benefit from 4 doses and evushield, but face a hard dilemma: how to balance living life with being safe? There is no one-size-fits-all answer. These discussions require a personal physician whom you trust.
Slowing spread in healthy young kids (vax’d or not), or among the vaccinated healthy adult population does not make sense anymore. They will all eventually be exposed, the vast majority will do well, and restrictions have serious costs on mental health, socialization, learning, depression, anxiety, weight, social isolation, mobility, and one’s life itself. The costs outweigh the benefits.
Policy makers need to be honest and tell the public what the goal is. Scientists need to run RCTs to see what interventions further that goal. Politicians need to realize they have painted themselves into this corner, and sadly many are in a bad situation. I am afraid the next time cases rise, we will simply tear each other apart, and have no plan at all.
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal
-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)
“surely at some point, they will climb. What will states do in response?”
The answer depends on the calendar. If it is before November, nothing will be done. After November, they are free to do whatever they want for a couple of years.
Had a nice talk with my 77-year-old sister who lives in a retirement community in Illinois. She finally said it. She thinks Covid is a sham as why has nobody in my very humongous family been mildly sick for more than a couple days. We have many family members in the 70’s and 80’s. I mentioned my trip to Florida and visiting our brother there. She agreed with us that the propaganda is the worst part of this plandemic, and she is utterly disgusted with it.
AK,feel you have probably seen this but if not,be inspired!
Mandates are forever in a post constitutional AmeriKa and in all the former ‘Free West.’ Get real. Next time any hesitancy to obey will be met with truncheons and chains.
Things would be a lot better if more people followed the maxim: “Don’t just DO something – sit there.”
Per fear porn NPR: It’s in North Carolina!
“The virus, known as BA.2, is a strain of the highly contagious omicron variant that appears to spread even more easily — about 30% more easily. And adding to the concern, one of the remaining antibody treatments for COVID-19 may be less effective against BA.2, according to recent research.
There are going to be plenty of people getting sick and ending up on respirators and dying because of BA.2,” says Dr. Jeremy Luban, a virologist at the University of Massachusetts Medical School, especially among the millions who still aren’t vaccinated.
Although vaccination and prior infection does appear to protect people against BA.2, this version of the virus seems somewhat better at evading the immune system than the original omicron was. This increases the concern that it could drive a growth in new cases.
And while Luban agrees the most likely scenario is that BA.2 will just extend the omicron wave, he says it’s impossible to rule out the possibility of another surge.
“It may be that the virus has to get to somewhere like 5-7%, and then all of a sudden once it has a foothold like that, it will take off,” Luban says.
Especially if that happens just as mask mandates and other restrictions are being lifted across the country and people are really letting down their guard.
“There is this lurking threat of BA.2. And we need to make sure this isn’t going to be a problem before we roll back all the mandates, before we tell everybody that it’s safe,” Scarpino says.
Otherwise, the nation could get blindsided yet again.”
And so it goes…………..
“This means Step 1: Document natural immunity. We have clear data now that natural immunity is very protective against future reinfection and hospitalization, so someone who has it can be left alone.”
Bullshit! Leave everyone alone!