Aw Crap….

Guest Post by Karl Denninger

Well, here’s the medical facts that entirely explain why people with more shots get more covid.

I’ve been paying attention to this possibility for a while but until the study work came out that proved it all there was is speculation.  ADE (“Antibody dependent enhancement”) is a fairly poorly-understood thing; most people believe it is confined to making a particular infection more serious than it would otherwise be.  Of course having it occur when it otherwise would not fits that quite-nicely, but isn’t what people tend to think about.

Now, unfortunately, we have the evidence.  Here’s the salient graph and lots of discussion which I’ll try to recap for you here:

Let me explain this one for you because it makes very clear what’s going on.  There are multiple sub-types of IgG antibodies.  IgG are the last ones that show up; IgA typically is in the mucosa of the nose, and is a “front line” of defense if you will.  IgM shows up second; it generally is gone about two weeks or so after you recover.  IgG is the “long term” antibody recognition but it has multiple subtypes.

This is very important for human and animal life, because not all things that can elicit a serious immune response should get one.  For example: A bee sting.  A serious immune response to that could kill you and in people seriously-allergic that’s a real risk.  So why don’t most people get a serious immune response?

As it turns out they sort of do, but its focuses in one sort of IgG build, IgG4, which suppresses the cascade of events that cause the body to go after the thing in question and destroy it, along with all the side effects that produces (fever, serious inflammation, etc.)

Well, when you get Covid typically IgG3 is the one that neutralizes most of the virus.  IgG1 and 2 do some of the work, but most of it is done by IgG3.  You’re not supposed to build an IgG4 response, and with natural infection without vaccination you don’t, thus there’s no inhibition and your response is and remains effective at neutralizing whatever it is.  Typical vaccines (e.g. measles) elicit a response that looks exactly like an actual infection because that’s how they’re designed and intended; they use the whole virus and their intent is to make your body think it is being invaded by the real deal and respond as it would to the real deal.

None of the western world Covid jabs do this on purpose.  They were all crafted to use only part of the virus, and the reason for that is past experience trying to create coronavirus vaccines all ended in failure with many of them producing wild enhancement of the infection instead of protection and in animal testing reliably killed the animals.  Thus the decision was made without long-term safety and efficacy testing to use only the spike, with the idea that doing so would prevent the bad outcome.

They were wrong; it didn’t prevent the bad outcome but instead shifted it in ways that were wildly insidious and unforeseen.

As it turns out what is now in the data is that IgG3, which the component that provides most of the protection against Covid is down to a flat zero by the time you take the third shot while IgG4 which causes the body to tolerate the infection and not clear it skyrockets from nothing prior to the second shot to being extremely high for the third and subsequent.

This was never detected in the trials because they didn’t look and it takes time to find it because the conversion only happens when you get infected after you’re jabbed. So if you only test for three months and don’t look at the IgG profile you’ll never see it happen, never mind that until you boost the data is that while its detectable after the second shot (and thus could have been detected if they bothered to look) the response curve is exponential and its the third one that basically zeros the IgG3 response if, following the first booster, you get infected again — and you will as neutralization from the booster itself wanes.

Remember, IgG4 causes the body to tolerate the infection rather than attack and clear it.

This turns you into a walking virus mutation and production factory, a source of infection to everyone around you and, to the extent that the virus does direct damage to your body systems, and we know the spike does, it also is likely to lead to very severe long-term problems that look like other conditions.  Nobody is looking for spike damage specifically in, for example, heart attacks, strokes and pulmonary embolisms, never mind the possibility of potentiating cancer by suppressing immune response if that suppression and tolerance goes beyond Covid, and it very well might.  If that’s not bad enough everyone that got jabbed has the same profile of response where the normal situation is that responses differ in different people because our body systems operate slightly differently (we’re all genetically unique.)

Now who’s most-likely to have had the most number of jabs and thus are walking around tolerating infections and giving them others?  Health care workers!  And who goes to the hospital or doctor? Compromised individuals who can least-withstand infections.  Gee, that was smart, right?

What’s worse is that we do not know if this is local to Covid or even just coronaviruses.  It might not be.  We may now have created a couple hundred million people in the US alone who have coded their immune systems to tolerate certain proteins that are common across all manner of respiratory viruses and worse, if its not local to viruses to be more-susceptible to cancer and other immune-sensitive problems with no way to reverse the effects!

If you recall I pointed out very early on in this thing that jabbing people with a non-sterilizing immune product, which these jabs all are, was wildly irresponsible because at minimum it would likely cause a decrease in symptoms and thus make it more likely rather than less that you’d go out and infect other people unknowingly.  That was and remains correct however what nobody knew because we didn’t look is that said non-sterilizing jabs had an even worse outcome in that they shift your immune response from elimination to tolerance so now, particularly after the third, you are likely to carry and not eliminate covid which makes you a literal Typhoid Mary, and if that’s not enough we have no idea if this effect is local to Covid itself (which, in the world of Omicron isn’t so awful as Omicron doesn’t seem to be killing many people) but it may extend to influenza and even RSV, and is even more-likely to extend to the other two common beta coronaviruses OC43 and HKU1.

And finally, this may be permanent in those people who took the jabs.  We don’t know.

But what we do know, factually, is that when you get infected with Covid post Jab #3 your neutralizing antibody product is a statistical zero while your “tolerance” antibody production shoots the moon.  This is exactly backward from what you want to happen and we are now left trying to figure out exactly how badly you screwed both yourself and others.

-----------------------------------------------------
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal

-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
54 Comments
Anonymous
Anonymous
December 27, 2022 3:36 pm

People who get shots are harmed and killed by them.

No one gets “covid” from anything. It doesn’t exist. The ruse of a disease is to manufacture compliance, via terrorism and threat of unemployment, to receive “help” from the protection racket that is .gov.

The brightest are often among those most fooled by indoctrination.

Why was is “covid-19” not called SARS-CoV-2, as SARS 1 from 2003 is called SARS-CoV-1?

C.ertificate
O.f
V.accine
I.
D.
1. (=A. rtificial)
9. (=I. ntelligence)

The occult-obsessed apex predators love their numerology/Gematria and other symbols. Symbols rule the world:

The Vigilant Citizen – Symbols Rule the World

AI: A Secular Look At The Digital Antichrist

https://www.technocracy.news/?s=occult

JimN
JimN
  Anonymous
December 27, 2022 3:55 pm

A reasoned comment with which I mostly agree. However, something has been infecting people globally. Maybe it’s just the flu by another name or maybe it is a man made bioweapon. But the important point as I’ve stated elsewhere is that nobody has ever isolated SARS-CoV-2 in the wild. That implies it’s a bioweapon if it can be said to exist.

The Central Scrutinizer
The Central Scrutinizer
  JimN
December 27, 2022 4:04 pm

Why stop there? Tell us what you really think.

AKJOHN
AKJOHN
  JimN
December 27, 2022 4:19 pm

I believe they are dropping bio-genetically altered Toxins on us. I had one attack my spinal Column after a Trump Rally. I was laid up fro 20 hours, and it took another two weeks to get back to 100%. Only a super immune system, and a diet loaded with vitamins and minerals saved me

everything is a ruse
everything is a ruse
  JimN
December 27, 2022 4:44 pm

The first place on earth to go online with 5g was wuhan China.

VOWG
VOWG
  JimN
December 28, 2022 6:53 am

as I have said many times now if it is a bioweapon it is the worst weapon ever with an IFR of 0.1%, revised form 0.26%. Influenza is deadlier. Stupid people believed the propaganda, took experimental mRNA and now are going to pay a terrible price for their stupidity.

Voltara
Voltara
  Anonymous
December 27, 2022 4:22 pm

You obviously haven’t had covid. It has a unique set of symptoms. This claim that covid does not exist has been disproven. Repeating this nonsense diminishes our credibility

Red River D
Red River D
  Voltara
December 27, 2022 4:45 pm

Whatever the hell I had a year ago August, was unlike anything I’ve ever had before. Felt like some kind of damn ALIEN flu. No bueno.

Everything is a ruse
Everything is a ruse
  Voltara
December 27, 2022 4:47 pm

No one has isolated it. WHY? Samples of viruses can easily be obtained from the deceased. All they have to do is take a sample and show it to the world as proof. Why hasn’t anyone done that?

Paleocon
Paleocon
  Everything is a ruse
December 27, 2022 6:55 pm

Here is only one of tens of thousands of papers that have isolated the virus that causes COVID-19. Give it a rest,
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7045880/

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Paleocon
December 27, 2022 7:02 pm

fedgov nat’l institutes of health – wonderful

It’s never been isolated, according to even the CD and FDA and many non-gov researchers. The PCR test is a lie.

You give it a rest.

VOWG
VOWG
  Paleocon
December 28, 2022 6:58 am

Ok sport, now tell us why there is no vaccine using the virus, purified and sterilized, that will actually do something other than create dangerous spike proteins that are harming millions and not preventing infection, transmission, illness or death.

VOWG
VOWG
  Voltara
December 28, 2022 6:54 am

I have had allergy attacks worse than “covid”.

Everything is a ruse
Everything is a ruse
  Anonymous
December 27, 2022 4:43 pm

Covid spelled backwards is DIVOC. Here’s what a divoc is:

https://jewish.shop/37046/what-does-divoc-mean-in-hebrew/

Spencer
Spencer
December 27, 2022 3:54 pm

I had a old friend before the Plandemic, that called me awhile back and said he would love to invite me to their poker game, if only I had the vaccine. I said, no problem, I don’t want to be around you guys because you all have taken the vaccine and your a bunch of dumb-asses, who wont spend 1/2 hour just looking into the jab and what it does beyond what CNN and Don Lemon says. He did not like my answer. LMAO

The Central Scrutinizer
The Central Scrutinizer
  Spencer
December 27, 2022 4:02 pm

“Ugly truth is unpalatable.” – Mark Twain

FWIW, I think you made the right choices.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Spencer
December 27, 2022 4:14 pm

Spencer these alleged friends are probably not going to be around much longer .
On a positive note , when these several million kick the bucket the used cars and vacant homes will be flooding the markets and social security will survive longer for us unjabbed pure bloods next healthy move is to rebuild the emergency blood supplies with untainted blood

Dying Sun
Dying Sun
  Anonymous
December 27, 2022 4:42 pm

I enjoy your sense of humor. It’s better to look at the positive outcomes than worry about the negative ones.

B_MC
B_MC
  Spencer
December 27, 2022 5:43 pm

comment image

VOWG
VOWG
  B_MC
December 28, 2022 7:00 am

I like that. I will use it.

Bill Clinton
Bill Clinton
December 27, 2022 4:05 pm

Two questions to those who have taken the shot: am I in your will and am I a beneficiary?

Red River D
Red River D
  Bill Clinton
December 27, 2022 4:47 pm

Today — EVERYONE I know who rolled up their sleeve is sick.

EVERYONE I know who refused, is not.

That’s some kind of ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE right there!!!

Abigail Adams
Abigail Adams
  Red River D
December 27, 2022 5:03 pm

Same. The people I know who got the shot currently have…covid.

The unjabbed…no covid.

When someone tells me they have covid, I reply, “But I thought you got the vaccine…and boosted?? I’m confused. I feel just fine – that’s weird.” (Just to be a little bit of an ass, cuz I can’t help myself sometimes.)

The True Nolan
The True Nolan
  Red River D
December 27, 2022 9:02 pm

Up until about two months ago my experience was the same as you. The vaxxed people I knew were (most of them) sick. The unvaxxed were either not sick or very minimally ill. The current flu wave has made EVERYONE sick in my little town, vaxxed or unvaxxed. Whatever the current virus is, it is nasty as hell. Extreme tiredness, hangs on for weeks. I take vitamins, minerals, and Ivermectin as a preventative — but it has kicked my butt!

frozenoutupnorth
frozenoutupnorth
  The True Nolan
December 28, 2022 1:32 am

I think that’s what the author of the article may be trying to point out. I’m unfortunately very familiar with the IgG’s (bee sting description) as my son has serious food allergies from early vaccines but we thank God he wasn’t an Autism statistic. His reaction taught us well for the upcoming propaganda onslaught since the doctors couldn’t wait to jab his tiny little body way back then, but we never dreamed they would attempt to genocide the planet. I’ve read the jabbed are amped up petri dishes of highly virulent strains of what we used to easily fight off.
Personally, I work with large groups of children, many of whom are jabbed and it’s been a winter of one nasty virus after another. It’s not the poison symptoms of last year but good old fashioned strep, sinus, cough, etc., only more so. Or, it might also be the realization of Fauci’s wet dream, to create a jab that transmits to unvaccinated. I’m getting a d-dimer test asap to see if I’ve been affected before Died Suddenly starts happening to even the unjabbed.

olde reb
olde reb
December 27, 2022 4:21 pm

The vax has been a giant step in acclimating the public to global submission. WHO has been able to get support for global lockdown after a pandemic declaration and to control global seaports..

“Is life so dear, and peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery ? Forbid it Almighty God. As for me, give me Liberty or give me death.” [Patrick Henry or Putin ?]

Carroll Quigley, William Blum, John Perkins, Douglas Valentine [CIA AS ORGANIZED CRIME ], and many more have documented the relentless spread of global domination that Klaus Schwab has promised the world. Rothschild’s have now started a control of money with central banks imposing a digital currency with the authority to remove all purchasing power from random selected individuals. That is slavery. They are usurping governments.

The Rothschild’s Federal Reserve has been shown to have embezzled $31 trillion from the USA citizens—and Biden and Congress are escalating their take. Even with 87,000 new armed IRS agents and an income tax law that does not exist. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals has declared the records are subject to GAO and FOIA demands. And we do nothing ???? Ref. https://genzconservative.com/the-federal-reserve-for-dummies/#_ftn3 FEDERAL RESERVE FOR DUMMIES

Anonymous
Anonymous
December 27, 2022 4:22 pm

Karl since your guest call ins on The Ron Smith show on radio known as “THE VOICE OF REASON” you have always been spot on with your research and facts leading to the conclusions that are informative and correct . You scare the idiots in DC so you are an unpopular gent .
Stay well and thanks , really miss Ron and can only imagine his thoughts and comments today !

Think
Think
December 27, 2022 4:40 pm

In Moderna’s animal trials all the animals who were jabbed died. Source: Dr. Carrie Madej.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Think
December 27, 2022 7:05 pm

Video of same info with Dr. Lee Merritt:

Dr. Lee Merritt: In Animal Studies, After Being Injected With MRNA Technology, All Animals Died Upon Reinfection

It really is VAIDS: vax-acquired immune deficiency syndrome.

GrungeVet
GrungeVet
December 27, 2022 4:41 pm

Karen Kingston and Dr. David Martin haver been hammering this home for over a year now. This is not new information, but it is good to finally hear smart people like Karl who have been so dismissive of the depopulation agenda finally have to admit the truth. These are not medical interventions.

They are BIOWEAPONS per 18 U.S. Code § 178:

(1)the term “biological agent” means any microorganism (including, but not limited to, bacteria, viruses, fungi, rickettsiae or protozoa), or infectious substance, or any naturally occurring, bioengineered or synthesized component of any such microorganism or infectious substance, capable of causing—
(A)death, disease, or other biological malfunction in a human, an animal, a plant, or another living organism;
(B)deterioration of food, water, equipment, supplies, or material of any kind; or
(C)deleterious alteration of the environment

Dr. David Martin’s Lawsuit Against Biden: “The COVID Injection Is a Bioweapon”

https://ugetube.com/watch/dr-david-martin-covid-vaccine-mrna-code-is-a-bioweapon-developed-via-a-digital-simulation_qvIggB3kqCHK12j.html

https://karenkingston.substack.com/p/911-patent-for-global-covid-19-vaccine

https://karenkingston.substack.com/p/part-1-dismantling-the-the-deceptions

https://karenkingston.substack.com/p/intended-consequences-mrna-vaccines

https://karenkingston.substack.com/p/by-calling-mrna-injections-covid

Covid is fake, deaths didn’t demonstrably rise in 2020, we don’t see that until 2021 and 2022. The healthy people killed off were largely done so via the mass murder protocols. The real weapon was always the jab, the rest of this was kabuki theater to get you and your loved ones to roll up their arm and inject their weapon right into your veins.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  GrungeVet
December 27, 2022 7:09 pm

Yep, flu cases just magically disappeared that year.

Steve Z.
Steve Z.
December 27, 2022 4:53 pm

I just found and read that article earlier today.
Karl does a great job explaining it. IgG3 goes to zero and IgG4 elevates….Oppps
It seems to be significant for ALL Coronaviruses. RSV is skyrocketing. Hospitals are swamped with the sick and it’s too early in the season for this type of event. Wait till late Jan-Feb….Ho Lee Shit…..
You better have Ivermectin handy and use an iodine based nasal spray before going out in crowds of any kind.
Below is a spray I’ve been using for 2 years. It’s highly effective, safe and very inexpensive (that’s why you’ll never hear anything about it from our medical community)…..I’ve not had any viral conditions for years, knock on wood.
I have no affiliation with this company. I just love the product.

Protect yourself and your patients. Instantly, and inexpensively. With Liquid Mask. ($3.75 a sprayer bottle – which lasts over 2 weeks for you or staff.)
Why Liquid Mask? The answer from Harvard professor Dr. S. V. Subramanian. His analysis in the European Journal of Epidemiology says that “sole reliance on vaccination as a primary strategy to mitigate COVID-19 and its adverse consequences needs to be re-examined. Other pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions may need to be put in place alongside increasing vaccination rates.”
Liquid Mask is a prime candidate. Logical, well-accepted, iodine-based, used in thousands of dental offices, hospitals, and medical offices daily.
You can read Dr. Subramanian’s Journal article HERE.
Please call for bulk pricing. 305 667-9375.

DougL
DougL
  Steve Z.
December 27, 2022 7:58 pm

Apparently the FDA has taken action so hope you have a solid supply — no longer seems available for sale. https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-criminal-investigations/warning-letters/iodine-products-inc-628296-03252022

Anonymous
Anonymous
December 27, 2022 6:08 pm

So the vaxxed-up get to keep on getting Covid over and over (possibly in addition to other respiratory viruses), and we, the unvaxxed also get to keep on getting it because they keep on getting it. The difference will be that our untainted immune systems will be able to handle it.
Herd immunity nullified BECAUSE of a “vaccine”.
It truly is now a pandemic of the “vaccinated”.

Glock-N-Load
Glock-N-Load
December 27, 2022 7:51 pm

My brother’s wife has 10 siblings (would have had 11 if one did not die at birth). All of them have children and some have grandchildren. Not a single one of them has had a medical issue with the jab..

Abigail Adams
Abigail Adams
  Glock-N-Load
December 27, 2022 7:54 pm

I believe you. There are many who still seem fine.

Have any of them had covid since being jabbed?

Glock-N-Load
Glock-N-Load
  Abigail Adams
December 27, 2022 9:24 pm

I don’t know the numbers of jabbed vs. not jabbed and I don’t know how many people in total. I’m also estranged from them. I hear through kther family members.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Glock-N-Load
December 28, 2022 6:56 am

“None has had an issue with the jab.”

“I don’t know the number jabbed vs unjabbed.”

“I’m estranged from them.”

Sounds scientific.

Glock-N-Load
Glock-N-Load
  Anonymous
December 28, 2022 7:14 am

I’ll be judging what’s true and not true by what’s happening around me from now on.

GNL
GNL
  Anonymous
December 28, 2022 8:07 am

My brother, his wife and his son took the jab. There’s a Dr. in her family and almost all (I’d bet 90%) of them are college educated. I’m betting it is a highly jabbed group.

rhs jr
rhs jr
  Glock-N-Load
December 27, 2022 10:03 pm

The bad doses went to Red states; are they in a Blue state?

Glock-N-Load
Glock-N-Load
  rhs jr
December 27, 2022 11:17 pm

MD

GNL
GNL
  rhs jr
December 28, 2022 8:05 am

Maryland

Dickie doo
Dickie doo
  Glock-N-Load
December 28, 2022 7:13 am

My brother, aunt, and niece all ended up in the hospital with heart issues shortly after the jab.

hardscrabble farmer
hardscrabble farmer
December 28, 2022 8:44 am

Rules for fitness of the human organism-

Live according to the seasons. Work longer hours in the Summer, rest more in the Winter, observe the way animals behave seasonally and mimic them. No one gives them direction and yet they all seem to be able to discern the difference in length of day and ambient air temperature and act accordingly.

Eat food that you have raised or that has been raised locally or sourced from places you know and trust. Avoid processed foods at all costs. As much as possible eat seasonally; fresh fruits and vegetables in season, meat based diets in colder months. Fermented foods should be a constant in your diet to maintain gut health.Moderate alcohol intake is beneficial, so too are natural stimulants like tea and coffee, in moderation.

Work physically for as many hours as you are capable at something productive. Make sure you use your whole body, and work to your limits whenever possible.

Drink plenty of water fresh from the well. Observe how often animals drink and how deeply.

Find things to keep your mind occupied in a positive manner; prayer, contemplation, planning, dwelling on things you have read or observed and try to find the connections and patterns between all of these things and apply them to your daily life whenever possible. Work at puzzles, solve problems, build or craft things whenever you can.

Spend a significant portion of your day outdoors in all weather and acclimate yourself rather than seek a way to avoid cold or inclement weather.

Find humor in all things, share it with those around you and use it to dispel anxiety by seeing the lighter side of even the darkest subjects.

Seek inspiration in others. Find great works to contemplate, either in music, art or writing and consider your connection to those who created them. Try to integrate those bbeautiful works into your own life and find ways to add to the tapestry of life with your own personal gifts and abilities.

Do for others as often as possible even when there is no reward for yourself. Selfless acts benefit greater numbers of people than those directed at personal gain. Share your skills freely and often and always be willing to accept a hand when offered. In this way true community is built and both the giver and recipient experience real connection to one another. Spend time in the company of people you love, admire and respect and avoid those who seek to cause turmoil or perpetuate discord.

Speak truthfully to others and seek the truth for yourself internally at all times, not to prove a point or to gain advantage, but to find harmony with your Nature and your purpose in life. Accept the things in life as they are rather than as you wish they were. More than anything you can do in life to find peace and contentment remember this; to thine own self be true.

Sleep well because you have labored intensely. A well worked day delivers a good night’s sleep. Before you drift off, think back on the day and what you have accomplished and where you have failed and consider the differences that led to each. Be content in your effort and thankful for the day.

Listen to your conscience, it understands you better than anyone else, knows your faults and your limitations and will never ask you to do anything that will bring you harm. Accept that everyone has moments of weakness and forgive those transgressions when they occur, but endeavor to erase them from your future actions. Hold yourself accountable rather than look for fault in externals.

This world consumes us all, our passage through it delivers us all to the same end, but the journey is one of sublime beauty if we only stay true to our destiny and perservere through whatever trials or setbacks may occur. The greatest gains in life are not the highlights or rewards, but the lessons learned from loss and failure. These strengthen us rather than tear us down if we possess the right frame of mind and remain constant in our values.

And above all things, be grateful, for this singular chance to experience the wonder, beauty and ineffable wonder that is life, not something we earned or sought, but a gift given to us freely by our Creator and seek to fulfill His plan for us no matter where it may lead. Give thanks for the day, no matter what it gives us, for there is a purpose under Heaven.

Svarga Loka
Svarga Loka
  hardscrabble farmer
December 28, 2022 9:03 am

I should keep that and write it on beautiful stationary in calligraphy to give to every child as it graduates as words of wisdom on how to live your life. Beautifully stated. Thank you.

Please put on your blog for future reference, but most definitely not under the “Aw crap” header.

MrLiberty
MrLiberty
December 28, 2022 12:46 pm

Unexpected, or exactly as designed?