1883: How the West Was Woke

Guest Post by Skinny

Spoiler Alert:  If you plan on ever watching this show stop reading now.  This is not a review but a rebuke and the entire story, above and between the lines, will be revealed.

1883 - Rotten Tomatoes

If you are unfortunate enough to watch the Yellowstone prequal 1883 you will be rewarded with the wokest revision of history since the 1619 project.  The heroes are, in rough order of appearance, James Dutton a former confederate officer and the patriarch of the Dutton family that some generations later will produce the modern version of this annoying family in the show Yellowstone.  His wife Margaret, played by Faith Hill, a joyless soul who face is permanently screwed up into a scowl.  Any appearance of a smile would cause her face to crack and shatter into hundreds of pieces and fall in shards onto the cruel baked earth.

Their daughter Elsa is a promiscuous 18 virgin who won’t remain so for long and their son John, who spends the majority of the series hiding in a foot locker.  The family is rounded out by Claire Dutton, widow of James’ brother Henry, and her last surviving daughter Mary Abel.  Compared to these two, the screwed up turnip face of Margaret is like a ray of sunshine.   The old west doesn’t tolerate many things one of which is puritanical severity.  So by the end of the second episode Mary Abel is offed by “bandits,” more on them later, and a distraught Claire offs herself with a bullet to the head.

The family is lured to Fort Worth, Texas and onto the frontier by an evil government promising them land and riches beyond their wildest dreams.

The government of 1883 isn’t the woke version that we see today where House of Representatives includes nagging sisters in arms like the squad who do heroic good deeds while being underappreciated by their republican colleagues and “bipartisan” show trials led by equally heroic black men.

No, there are no black men in the government of 1883.  The House is made up by white men with either long white beards or snaky “Snidely Whiplash” type mustaches that they like to twirl while they snigger with greed.  The Senate is made up in its entirety by the Ku Klax Klan.

The evil government convinces this hard-working group that they must go west to pursue their American Dream while what they really want is for them to kill as many Indians as possible and tame the west for their own greedy interests.

In Fort Worth, the cheerful family meets up with a pair of grizzled veterans of both the Union Army and the old west, Captain “Wrong Way” Shea Brennan and Thomas, Who May or May Not Have a Last Name.  Wrong Way earns his name by consistently heading in the wrong direction whenever trouble, typically in the form of the above-named bandits arrives.  Furthermore, it is commanders like Wrong Way that explains how the woefully undermanned, under gunned and otherwise under equipped  Confederate army almost won the Civil War.  Thomas is the levelheaded black man that every woke tale requires.

It is also here in Fort Worth that Wrong Way and Thomas agree to guide a hoard of German Gypsies from Texas to Oregon.  That the gypsies are woefully unprepared for the trip does not deter Shea and so he makes the first in an unending series of horrible decisions.  Getting every decision wrong is as statistical impossible as is getting every decision right.  Wrong Way provides the necessary exception proving this rule.

It is also in Fort Worth that we discover that all evil in the West is caused by white men.  The drunks, white men.  The carousers, white men.  All forms of oafish, boorish behaviour, white men.  The loutish list is topped by a drunk carousing oaf, who mistakenly crashes into Elsa’s room, and instead of apologizing and retreating, does what all white men must do, attempt to rape the 17-year-old girl in a crowded hotel.  James hears the commotion and quickly arrives to shoot the man dead before his lecherous activities come to fruition.  Many witnesses soon arrive and all nod knowingly secure in the knowledge that all white men are pigs.  It never occurred to anyone to ask, “what the hell was that guy thinking?”  Do you really think you can rape 17-year-olds  in the middle of a crowded hotel without repercussions?”  Get used to it folks, this is foreshadowing a recurring theme.

Foregoing the relative safety of the town, Wrong Way leads the gypsy caravan out of town and promptly takes off in search of wild cattle.  Joining him are all the non gypsy men and all the firearms leaving the camp entirely unprotected.  On cue, the all-white bandits show up, and after Claire Dutton starts a ridiculous rock fight, proceed to shoot up the camp killing Mary Abel Dutton along with several gypsies.  The narrative that all white men are capable of is raping and killing underage girls is firmly established.

Later on, the caravan crosses the Brazos River (with predictably disastrous results) Wrong Way announces to James Dutton, that they have now entered “Bandit Country.”  In olden days when John Wayne crossed the Brazos he was entering “Indian Country.”  The significance is not lost and is reaffirmed when the group meets up with two Comanches who are as fun loving as they are helpful.  One of them named Sam, is so playful and helpful he engages in horse races then beds then weds the no longer innocent Elsa.  These Indians, er Native Americans are so helpful they even ride back into the teeth of a tornado to help their new friends.  Good luck getting a White Bandit to do that.  The ever-helpful Sam even teaches his new bride the Comanche language which she will use to save her life later in the series.

Even when the Indians are at last moved to violence it is the fault of white bandits.  The otherwise peaceful Lakota Indians go on the warpath only after their women and children are slaughtered by the nasty bandits and then the bandits due the unthinkable, steal their horses.  Killing the womenfolk is bad enough, but stealing horses, beyond the pale.  In yet another example of Wrong Way blunders, he takes all the guns and men to chase the bandits leaving the group unprotected yet again.  The Lakota ignore Wrong Way’s legion and take off after the rest of the group killing more innocents and mortally wounding Elsa.  Elsa’s mastery of the Indian language learned after just on tutelage session at her husband’s knee convinces the Lakota to ride off thus saving her and the rest of the group a painful torturous death.  The woke timeline reads, bad white men inflame noble red men to righteous anger and the female of the species invokes civility.

The 1619 project invokes wokeness into the American founding and 1883 continues this nonsense into the settling of the West.  Coming soon, 1920 and the Wokeness of Prohibition.

-----------------------------------------------------
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal

-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)
Click to visit the TBP Store for Great TBP Merchandise
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
39 Comments
KJ is a faggot
KJ is a faggot
August 5, 2022 3:14 pm

First episode looked like it had some promise. By the third episode, things looked bad. By the fifth, it was a very unfunny joke. Stopped watching.

First day, one person of the immigrant party can kind of speak English. A week later dozens can and even manage to argue and insult in English?

And yes, the “Mary Sue’ and woke became ridiculous.

Other things? Every person had perfect white teeth. A double barrel shotgun is fired three times without reload.

Someone on IMDB summed it up nicely, “The memoir of a teen narcissist”

Anonymous
Anonymous
  KJ is a faggot
August 5, 2022 3:57 pm

“First episode looked like it had some promise.”

Any thoughts on Yellowstone?

KJ is a faggot
KJ is a faggot
  Anonymous
August 5, 2022 4:12 pm

It has some flaws but nothing like 1883.

The gunplay and lack of any accountability seems a bit far fetched, but overall enjoyable IMO. Good but not great.

The stuff in the ranch hands quarters is usually pretty funny. The black guy cracks me up. He seems long suffering being probably the smartest of the bunch and having to put up with them.

Kind of like Sons of Anarchy with horses instead of bikes.

Colorado Artist
Colorado Artist
  Anonymous
August 5, 2022 4:27 pm

Yellowstone is Sopranos in cowboy boots.

KJ is a faggot
KJ is a faggot
  Colorado Artist
August 5, 2022 4:29 pm

That too.

Anon y mous
Anon y mous
  Colorado Artist
August 5, 2022 6:46 pm

Thank you – I’ve been telling my wife it is the Godfather in Montana. And – just like the Godfather or other mafia movies, Yellowstone is hard to watch. Unlike mafia movies there is not really one good character in this show. All are despicable and immoral human beings who cannot complete one sentence without the word f..k in it.

keann
keann
  Anonymous
August 6, 2022 5:46 am

Mine – bored with Beth, Jaime and John Dutton would never vote for Liz Cheney. No “next” season for me…

Anonymous
Anonymous
  KJ is a faggot
August 5, 2022 4:08 pm

And…”A double barrel shotgun is fired three times without reload.”

thought ONLY brandon had one of THAT particular model?

Colorado Artist
Colorado Artist
  Anonymous
August 5, 2022 4:38 pm

The most ludicrous bit of 1883 is the Comanche being
in any way friendly to whites. I’ve made a study of plains Indians,
and the Comanche were the fiercest, most savage of all the tribes.
Everyone feared them and never suffered a defeat from fellow Indians
or whites until Samuel Colt’s Walker revolver and then repeating rifles.
“Empire Of The Comanche Moon” is a nice introduction to them.
1883 is pure Hollywhore hokum that checks all the lib boxes..

KJ is a faggot
KJ is a faggot
  Colorado Artist
August 5, 2022 4:44 pm

Watch The Son to see that. Nasty bit of torture.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Colorado Artist
August 6, 2022 2:28 pm

Empire of the *Summer* Moon. Great book.

Skinny
Skinny
  KJ is a faggot
August 5, 2022 4:27 pm

You should have stayed with it. You missed Wrong Way offing himself at the very end. Highlight of the entire series.

Jason Calley
Jason Calley
  KJ is a faggot
August 5, 2022 6:22 pm

Only three shots from a double barrel shotgun? Amateurs!

KJ is a faggot
KJ is a faggot
  Jason Calley
August 5, 2022 6:40 pm

That was better than expected.

Westworld had a couple of interesting lever gun scenes where it ejected the spent cartridge on firing. Then again when the lever was actuated.

How hard is it to get this right? I notice immediately and I am not a continuity expert or armorer.

Paleocon
Paleocon
  KJ is a faggot
August 6, 2022 3:34 am

I stopped in the middle of the season too and really appreciate this article.

micky
micky
August 5, 2022 3:17 pm

To hate for white people and the founding of his formerly great nation is being driven by “chosen tribe” that dominates the current Washington regime, banking, media and tech giants.
They are smart , well funded and are weaponizing blacks to kill the shrinking majority.
Why???
To rule in the ruins?
One world government??
Just because???

another Doug
another Doug
  micky
August 5, 2022 3:25 pm

Old habits die hard.

Steve Z.
Steve Z.
August 5, 2022 3:26 pm

Another Netflix production?
BTW, Netflix is hemorrhaging customers.
Everyone has had their fill of this BS wokeness.

Anonymous
Anonymous
August 5, 2022 4:24 pm

Putting to much into this 1883 fictional drama !
The big issue today is mind control and brainwashing with the likes of Sesame Street .
Sure 1883 has its politically correct woke digs but nothing like all tv today , street thug BLM,s and illegals all played out as hero’s and all the lbgqt … accepted as normal .
Every family show portrays the white male father as a blithering idiot being corrected by the 9 year old daughter and the gay couple next door keeps stupid white man from burning the house down while starting a lawnmower in the drive way or changing the lightbulb in the kitchen . Thank god these smart ass kids and butt fuckers are handy otherwise white men would be on the endangered list !
Oh that’s right we are !

Jason Calley
Jason Calley
  Anonymous
August 5, 2022 6:28 pm

And everyone knows that a 105 pound, 14 year old girl with no training, can beat up a 35 year old, 225 pound, trained assassin, holding with a knife in each of his hands. Happens all the time. And then she hotwires his car in a few seconds and drives away at 120mph.

In the movies.

MiRVCHUK
MiRVCHUK
August 5, 2022 5:17 pm

“Spoiler Alert: If you plan on ever watching this show stop reading now. This is not a review but a rebuke and the entire story, above and between the lines, will be revealed.”

Why would I watch a TV show? It’s TV. What did you expect? Are you retarded?

Ginger
Ginger
August 5, 2022 5:27 pm

Actually the Confederate Army was one of the best equipped Armies in the World at the time except for numbers of troops. They invented the submarine, the ironclad battleship, torpedoes, land mines, star-burst artillery shells. They used observation balloons and launched them off barges. They had more artillery per hundred men. They just lacked men.
Read a book on Spotsylvania Courthouse and it spoke of the front line men would have five or six rifles each. The rifle pits there are unbelievable, General Lee built a military road and sent engineers to set it up while fighting the battle of The Wilderness. The North would attack and not even let the men load their guns, just use shear groups of bodies.
My Great Grand-Uncle was killed and buried there blunting Hancock’s attack at the Mule Shoe or Bloody Angle.
At both The Wilderness and the night of the attack at Spotsylvania General Lee personally led counter-attacks on horse back, no Major General has ever done that since. His father was the famous Revolutionary War cavalry leader General Lighthorse Henry Lee.

mark
mark
  Ginger
August 5, 2022 6:57 pm

1,000 + Ginger.

I was born a Yankee…but live as a Rebel…by choice.

I love the Deep South, all of its wonderful pure culture and have spent most of my adult life immersed in its beauty.

I also claim an amazing battle scared Confederate General as kin from my Mick half…I’d put him up but I don’t want to dox myself.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVeSKwM–1M

When it comes time to fight again…and it is almost here…I will wear Butternut.

https://1860s.blogspot.com/2008/11/confederate-butternut-soldier.html

YourAverageJoe
YourAverageJoe
  Ginger
August 5, 2022 10:03 pm

They also had blockaded coasts.
Thank Russia for keeping England from supporting the Confederacy by foiling England’s support via naval action.
Dammit.

flash
flash
  Ginger
August 6, 2022 9:42 am

Total bullshit.

The Army of Tennessee, for which my great great grandpas fought , hadn’t enough of anything and the South never did recover from the brutal ass rape of Money Lender Imperialism. It’s mostly still a third world shithole today.

Drawing on memoirs and a trove of unpublished letters and diaries, Walker follows the soldiers of the Fifty-seventh as they push far into Unionist Kentucky, starve at the siege of Vicksburg, guard Union prisoners at the Andersonville stockade, defend Atlanta from Sherman, and more. Hardened fighters who would wish hell on an incompetent superior but break down at the sight of a dying Yankee, these are real people, as rarely seen in other Civil War histories.

Also the Army of Northern Virginia didn’t fair much better.

In the middle of September 1862, war tramped barefoot, dirty and disheveled into Washington County in western Maryland. It came in the form of Rebel soldiers whose clothes were muddy and mismatched, and who kept having to run off behind the bushes to flush the effects of unripe corn and green apples. For citizens of this rural county, the war seemed more of a traveling freak show than a threat. Most residents who made their living off the sticky clay soil of the Cumberland Valley knew only what they read in the papers, and the Hagerstown Herald of Freedom and Torch Light disdainfully wrote off the ragtag, hungry-eyed Southern band half marching, half straggling into town:

[T]heir cause is well nigh hopeless. Though determined to fight to the last, they cannot withstand during the coming winter the combined attacks of starvation, cold and our army; and then, if for no other reason, their cause must fail for want of inherent strength to sustain it.

The condition and morale of the army is beyond description. They came among us not only badly clothed and unclean in person, but in a half-starving condition. For days, indeed, since the fights at Centreville, they have subsisted on rations of bread, irregularly issued, and green corn and fruits. Hundreds are weakened by diarrhea, and worn out by their long march, but they fight desperately because forced by hunger and want. Many express an ardent desire to lay down their arms, while on the other hand the officers and those better cared for are determined to fight to death rather than submit.

Army Of Northern Virginia

fujigm
fujigm
August 5, 2022 5:37 pm

I didn’t read it.
It was kind of long.
And I don’t watch TV.

B.S. in V.C.
B.S. in V.C.
August 5, 2022 7:43 pm

communist always want to rewrite history.

YourAverageJoe
YourAverageJoe
August 5, 2022 9:38 pm

I cross the Brazos twice everytime I go to my alternate, out of the city, bug-out property twice. I have never encountered any scandalous activity either way.
As a Texan, I am always armed and ready to defend myself from any threats, black or White.

Oh…we’re talking about a fantasy teevee show here, ain’t we?
Sorry

Machinist
Machinist
  YourAverageJoe
August 6, 2022 7:13 am

Bet you’re seeing your Sweetie…

[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3U4HtnXbNd4&w=839&h=629%5D

ken31
ken31
August 5, 2022 10:48 pm

“Tame the West for their own greedy interest” is not woke, it is what really happened.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  ken31
August 6, 2022 2:20 am

Not exactly

ken31
ken31
  Anonymous
August 6, 2022 1:21 pm

I guess some of us have longer memories.

Winchester
Winchester
August 6, 2022 9:01 am

I love a series set in historical context, especially early American times. As far as 1883, it hits the mark as far as historical setting, outside of a few errors with firearms that did not quite exist yet. It is was a joy to watch in that respect.

Those were the good, but there were many bads. Starting with the daughter who seems to be the person that most of the plot of the show centers around. Teenage girls, like other kids, would be seen, but not heard in that era. For the sake of historical context, she didn’t have an iPhone or sit there on Tik Tok all day, but she could have easily been doing that based on how she was portrayed. Her interaction with adults and involvement in certain activities during that period would not have happened. She wouldn’t have been roping cattle, banging a cowboy, fighting grown men, and especially wouldn’t have ran off with an Indian.

The second thing that bothered me with the show was the politically correct injection of a black man fraternizing with an immigrant, who happened to be white. He was a union veteran, which was not historically wrong as many blacks served in armies on both sides. He was also a freed man, which would allow him to be on the trek out west and not some slave on the plantation. Everyone knows that even after the war, blacks were not exactly treated as equals to whites. Looking at the character one would think that blacks were completely accepted as equals and were never slaves. With that said, other than Sam Elliot, the black guy was definitely my favorite character and a good actor overall.

I guess if you like historical dramas, especially for their attention to detail, and don’t mind the politically correct nonsense, it is worth the watch.

flash
flash
August 6, 2022 9:25 am

Who watches Hollyfag socials justice historical fiction bullshit when they’re are so many real history books available for free download ?

e.g.

https://www.libgen.is/

https://archive.org/

For me, there’s nothing more annoying than when some halfwit fanboy starts telling me, in great boring detail, about this movie/series they saw, and how I should watch it…or their recent sportsball experience… makes me want to reach out and touch someone.

Aunt Acid
Aunt Acid
  flash
August 6, 2022 11:54 pm

Tel Avi\/sion?
History books?

ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING Auntie?

The Evil Fuckers have locked down the world, made shots compulsory, shut businesses and churches, prohibited visitations to old people…engaged in war crimes against humanity and a vast majority of people, even some here at TBP, are watching a stupid fucking tv show?

Only the Lord God can help the world. In the meantime, read some Army field manuals with some emphasis on asymmetrical activities. We are gonna need it.

Rev6
Rev6
August 6, 2022 12:50 pm

Worthless shows – Tim McGraw and Faith Hill can sing but they can’t act – who are those other actors sam somebody in every western and the actor in “If you build it they will come movie – baseball field” He never could act…………….the only review I could give to any of the clips I saw would be several puke emojis but I don’t know how to post those – insert smile emoji here…………what I did see of the shows, especially Yellowstone was normalizing murder if Dutton didn’t get his way and what’s his name RIP??? How appropriate as he would take anyone to the train station and send them to their final rest………….and yeah Faith Hill and Tim McGraw went down a zillion pegs for me, can’t even hear or see them without the 1883 interface on them.

Jdog
Jdog
August 6, 2022 1:26 pm

Boycott Hollywood.
If you truly want to change things, it will take some sacrifice on your part. Despite all the bitching on this site, none of you is even willing to stop watching the movies made by the communists who are stealing your freedoms. When totalitarianism comes, you will be as responsible as anyone for what is happening.

Aunt Acid
Aunt Acid
  Jdog
August 6, 2022 11:55 pm

Exactly right, JDog.

Mass A.
Mass A.
March 28, 2023 5:56 am

All one liners basically. The Woke reeks. So sad, it could have been a good effort.
But the woke ruined it, as Always. Yellowstone just as blind.