Kill People, No Problem… Just Don’t “Cheat” Uncle

Guest Post by Eric Peters

A VW engineer may be going to prison – and has already been professionally (and probably personally) ruined… for having “cheated” the EPA. Which is like expelling a picked-on kid who outsmarted the playground bully.

Which, of course, is what often happens now.

Whether it’s the schoolyard bully – or the EPA (or other “agencies” of Uncle) – we are supposed to take it, never resist it – and may the motor gods have mercy upon you if you ever “cheat” it.

The engineer’s name is James R. Liang. He’s worked for VW since 1983, but not anymore. Bye-bye career (and pension) and hello Federal prison. Which he’s facing on account of having been a member of the engineering team that developed “defeat” software for VW’s TDI diesel engines. The software made the engines “compliant” when emissions tested by Uncle but less-than-compliant when driven by customers.

-----------------------------------------------------
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal

-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)

As I’ve written about several times before, this sounds bad but really isn’t. The EPA’s tests are both arbitrary and Pecksniffian – meaning much ado about not much. The media continues to parrot the line that VW’s diesel engines produced “up to 40 times” more pollution (specifically, oxides of nitrogen) than the EPA’s standards permitted.

   

Maybe so. But – so what?

It continues to boggle sensible minds (if any still exist) that EPA hasn’t had to produce any evidence that harm has been caused by this. Not one crying baby, even. Probably because the “up to 40 times more” the media keeps squawking about amounts to less than 1 percent’s difference in the composition of the “cheating” car’s exhaust gasses.

The only thing that’s been established is that VW “cheated” – which is a legalism.

The German officers who conspired to get rid of the Fuhrer in July of 1944 were certainly guilty under the law. But did they do wrong? History has vindicated them (too late for them, of course).

Maybe events will be kinder to Liang. Maybe it will occur to his lawyers to ask the Never Asked Question: Where is the victim of this alleged crime?

Just one.

Arguing anything else is a loser. VW, via painful-looking public hairshirted writhings,has already admitted to “cheating” EPA. Now it is just a question of begging for mercy – which will never be given. EPA is like Al Sharpton who has found a “racist.”

Never forgive. Never shut up.

Liang himself has already begged for mercy – and is cooperating with Uncle’s Inspector Javerts in exchange (he hopes) for “leniency” when he is eventually sentenced for “violating U.S. clean air laws” and “conspiring to commit wire fraud.” The indictment handed down against him states that Liang and other engineers at VW “…quickly realized the diesel engines they were designing for vehicles target at the U.S. market could not meet government clean air standards while appealing to customers.”

Italics added.

Yes, exactly. VW’s “crime” was building engines that appealed to its customers – rather than building them to placate EPA. For this “crime,” Liang will probably spend time in a prison cell. It may not be hard-core prison and he may “get away” with house arrest, an ankle bracelet and probation – along with a healthy does of financial ruin and (as a result of all the foregoing) a ruined marriage. But consider his fate as opposed to some of the Wall Street crony capitalists of the Late Implosion (back in ’08) who caused actual harm to millions of people and who for the most part walked away with not so much as a parking ticket and in many cases, a golden parachute strapped to their backs.

And what about the war criminals in the government – the same government that is hounding engineers like Liang – who (The Chimp, for instance) are directly responsible for the calculated, deliberate murder of tens of thousands of people (low estimate) and who now (as The Chimp likes to) sit at home doing watercolors?

These actual harms triggered no consequence to speak of. Because their perpetrators did not commit the only crime that Uncle will not tolerate: Failing to obey.

That is Liang’s – and VW’s – fatal offense. They could have designed and sold shoddy cars that resulted in accidents and fatalities – actual harm caused to actual real people – and the worst that would have happened would have been recalls and lawsuits. They’d have lost some money, perhaps. But it is not likely anyone would have been criminally prosecuted.

Speaking of which: Ever wonder why that old bag Joan Claybrook (and Elizabeth Dole, wife of Bob, who, as Secretary of Transportation back in the ’80s, was also directly responsible for the harm that ensued) were never indicted for getting people killed by forcing the first-generation air bags onto the market, even though they knew ahead of time – because the engineers told them – that these bags were not just potentially but assuredly dangerous to small children, older people and people generally?

These bags – which were not “de-powered” and lacked sensors in the seats to adjust the force of deployment based on the weight of the occupant, to reduce (but not eliminate) the potential harm caused by the force of the bag’s explosive deployment – did in fact kill and maim. Real people were really hurt.

But Claybrook and Dole were never held accountable – because in their death-dealing they were Uncle manifested. And Uncle never indicts – much less convicts – himself. Or his minions.

But woe unto him who “cheats” Uncle.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
18 Comments
Anonymous
Anonymous
January 5, 2017 8:57 am

The rules are a bad idea in the first place, probably of little or no value in terms of actual air quality, but until they are changed they are still the rules.

They are, whether just or unjust, the law.

Liang knew the rules, he deliberately broke them. He know there could be consequences for breaking them but he did it anyway expecting to get away with it undetected.

I have a hard time feeling sorry for him anymore than I have for anyone else that knowingly breaks the law without regard for the consequences of it.

This isn’t a victimless crime, the victims are all the other players in the automotive game that played by the rules and lost sales to the dishonest player that cheated at the game.

Mstrjack
Mstrjack
  Anonymous
January 5, 2017 9:20 am

In our world you could literally be sentenced to jail for not using your turn signal. Don’t pay the fine and see what happens. You know the law. Do you ALWAYS use your turn signal? Maybe there are too many laws and too much punishment. Maybe the law isn’t about safety. Perhaps is is just about the money. Private prisons.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Mstrjack
January 5, 2017 9:42 am

I’d love to play poker with you.

You wouldn’t expect me to play by the same rules you and everyone else in the game is expected to play by.

If you don’t like the rules, the laws, change them, don’t simply ignore them and get indignant about the consequences when you get caught doing it.

As for me, I’ve had two tickets in over 50 years of driving, both because I ignored posted speed limits, and I paid both tickets without blaming anything or anyone other than myself for getting them.

Jeremy
Jeremy
  Anonymous
January 12, 2017 4:17 pm

Consider it like this, in the aforementioned Poker game, what would be worse, someone cheating while you’re just playing for fun, or cheating when the loser gets mamed or killed?

kokoda the deplorable
kokoda the deplorable
  Anonymous
January 5, 2017 11:04 am

Anon………ever hear of jury nullification? The point is – if a law is unjust then decency should prevail. Although this was not a jury, if it was I would not convict.

I would like to know why his legal side didn’t pursue the ‘nobody was harmed’ defense.

Leonard
Leonard
  Anonymous
January 5, 2017 12:01 pm

Not to mention the consumers, who may find themselves unable to renew registration on their vehicles because bureaucrats in their states will strictly enforce the emissions laws within their states so as not to risk loss of the federal money that comes to the state as a result of having adopted the so-called “clean air” laws…

Rick Caird
Rick Caird
  Anonymous
January 5, 2017 8:01 pm

I disagree. It would not be hard for VW to find a significant road in, say Kansas, where driving conditions would match the EPA test and the lower levels would kick in. Sowing just one occurrence would eliminate the whole EPA charade.

Mstrjack
Mstrjack
January 5, 2017 9:11 am

Good Article! This ‘State’ that the creepy Uncle Sam is in charge of is completely twisted. They steal from all the productive people through income taxes. Think about it. Income Tax is slavery. If the Income Tax was 100% of everyone’s pay then it would be easy to see the slavery. Since it is only 35%, then people just pay the criminals in order to stay out of jail for tax evasion. Jail (private prisons for profit) is a terrible blight on society. Cages, and slop, should only be for violent people who prove they can not behave in society … like the warmonger George H. W. Bush and his warmongering son George W. Bush and the like.

“Jail is depressing because it shuts off the world. It leaves one caught in the dull monotony of sameness. It is almost like being dead while one still lives.” – Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Dr. King’s crime … non-violent protests for equal treatment under the law.

kokoda the deplorable
kokoda the deplorable
  Mstrjack
January 5, 2017 11:06 am

Mstrjack….besides the two Bush’s, why didn’t you add Obama and Hillary?

unit472
unit472
January 5, 2017 9:55 am

Bureaucrats in Europe decided diesels were the better technology so European car makers focused on diesel engines. The bureaucrats in Europe are now having second thoughts but no matter, VW and other European car companies had to sell what they knew how to make.

Since consumers ( the actual owners of the cars) value fuel economy and performance over emission standards VW gave priority to meeting its customers preferences and making the engine ‘smart’ enough to meet emission standards only when it was being tested for emissions.

I’ve wondered just how many VW and Audi turbo diesel owners have actually showed up at North American dealerships demanding their cars performance be degraded to meet EPA standards. Oh I’m sure they will all accept compensation from VW for the deception but I doubt few if ANY will voluntarily submit to having their car engines detuned to reduce performance.

I’m hoping Trump gets the EPA out of anything but minimum emission and fuel economy standards and lets the manufactures produce the cars it can sell to its customers.

If that means Cadillac thinks it can sell an ultra high end El Dorado that weighs 6000 lbs let them. It won’t affect the sales of Chevy subcompacts because they are separate markets. Get rid of CAFE standards altogether. Customers know a 500 horsepower Mustang is not going to get good fuel economy but if they are paying an extra $25,000 for the performance model they aren’t looking for fuel economy.

AA
AA
January 5, 2017 10:08 am

This is not about the cars, or the air, it is about money.

The Germans wanted to repatriate their gold from Uncle just about the same time the EPA claims to have found the cheating.

coincidence?

Bullshit or not, you make the call.

TC
TC
  AA
January 5, 2017 2:19 pm

Interesting observation. Seem to remember that the discovery that VW was cheating had been made a year or more before Uncle decided to make a big deal of this. Helluva coincidence.

Hoboken411
Hoboken411
January 5, 2017 10:30 am

“Anonymous” commenter in this thread is an a-hole. Socialist scum. “Play by the rules” is their argument along with other circular reasonings. Incapable of understanding these stupid “laws” – why they should NOT exist and should be ignored.

Probably ratted on kids in kindergarten for coloring outside the lines, too.

A poster child of what the government wants every citizen to act like.

Anonymous
Anonymous
  Hoboken411
January 5, 2017 11:02 am

Yeah, and do you support illegal immigration too, in spite of it violating the rules (something you seem to have disdain for)?

Either you do or you are a hypocrite that believes one set of rules should be applied to things you support and a different set to those you don’t.

Don’t be an idiot, when you enter a game it is understood that you have agreed to play by its rules.

kokoda the deplorable
kokoda the deplorable
  Anonymous
January 5, 2017 11:12 am

Anon….lay off the booze. Illegal immigration: we have a different set of laws already on the books. If one of those character was brought before a jury and I was on the jury, and the perp was charged for illegal entry due to laws on the books, AND I agreed with those laws (I do), then I would convict.

Yes, I do get to choose what laws I deem to violate my standards of right vs wrong.

starfcker
starfcker
  kokoda the deplorable
January 5, 2017 1:08 pm

A lot of the bullshit we have had to deal with should disapear pretty quick. Because our world has been upside down for so long, it’s easy to think it’s permanent. Prosperity both for the country and individuals, is an easy formula. Abundant work, and low cost of living. Trump knows this.

Anon
Anon
January 5, 2017 6:14 pm

Yawn, Anonymous. Come talk to me about the rule of law when John Corzine (who BTW just got off with a measly 5,000,000 fine for defrauding farmers out of 1.5 Billion – not bad return on investment) http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-01-05/jon-corzine-settles-over-mf-global-collapse-agrees-lifetime-bar-5-million-fine ,
when the medical monopolists go to jail for fraud and violation of the Gramm-Leach Bailey act, when John Stumpf goes to prison for bank fraud against millions of depositors, Fast and Furious, well, you get the idea. I agree that laws should apply to everyone, and the rule of law must be imposed. HOWEVER, the author of this is spot on. The laws are currently decided more about WHO it is, and what campaign contributions / alliances the person / business has instead of whether there were actual harm committed. In the 70’s we had real muscle cars that emitted far more exhaust than any of these VW’s ever could, and somehow we kept on breathing. This whole nonsense about globull warming is just that – libtard nonsense. I say fine VW and move on. I could only wish I was on that jury.

gilberts
gilberts
January 5, 2017 8:05 pm

Yeah, but I don’t care. I was one of the people who got screwed-I bought one of those cars. I liked the car when it performed as I thought it was supposed to, but I was cheated by VW when they sold me a car that was not in compliance with the law. The car can either be efficient and reliable or it can be legal; it can’t be both. I don’t want that car if it’s going to be “fixed” to run poorly and cleanly and legally. That’s not what I bargained for when I got it. So now VW is buying my car back from me. They’re offering about 15.5K, but that’s not actually what I’ll get. Once I filled out all their paperwork and mailed in my documents, they sent a final offer letter with the caveat that I will not get 15.5K if the car was driven more than 12.5K miles a year. WTF? I put at least 20K a year on it every year I owned it. At this point, i’ll take whatever they offer as long as it’s above fair market value for a Satanic environmental-holocaust-denier murder-death-kill I-Love-Pollution diesel lungcancer deathwagen.

Also, there are NO good guys in this story. The engineer isn’t some kind of victim or underdog. He and VW are complicit in a conspiracy to violate our stupid nation’s stupid laws. That’s a crime and it’s no different than any other corporate conspiracy to cheat consumers. The USG is also a bad guy for fucking up the auto industry with their command economy Soviet-style controls and general asshattery picking winners and losers and driving our costs up and our jobs overseas. The only victims in this story are you and I. If only we could fix the root cause of our suffering.