Guest Post by Jeffrey A. Tucker
One day I’m reading an internal memo commissioned by the Democratic Party to provide advice to dealing with Covid policy. The next day I’m reading headlines about how the CDC has drastically altered its advice on how to deal with Covid.
Is there a relationship? At this point, only the hopelessly naive would think otherwise.
Let’s look at the memo produced by Impact Research. Some excerpts:
- Democrats have a tremendous opportunity to claim an incredible, historic success – they vaccinated hundreds of millions of people, prevented the economy from going into freefall, kept small businesses from going under, and got people back to work safely. Because of President Biden and Democrats, we CAN safely return to life feeling much more normal – and they should claim that proudly.
- Six in ten Americans describe themselves as “worn out” by the pandemic. The more we talk about the threat of COVID and onerously restrict people’s lives because of it, the more we turn them against us and show them we’re out of touch with their daily realities.
- [I]t means recognizing that the threat of COVID is no longer what it was even a year ago and therefore should not be treated as such – shutdowns, masks, and lockdowns were meant to save lives when there was not yet a vaccine that could do that. Voters know we now have the tools in the toolkit to be responsible in combatting and living with COVID – vaccines and boosters to minimize illness, and masks and social distancing around vulnerable groups.
- They think the virus is here to stay, and 83% say the pandemic will be over when it’s a mild illness like the flu rather than COVID being completely gone, and 55% prefer that COVID should be treated as an endemic disease. And that’s what most Americans are dealing with—a disease with fatality rates like the flu—because most of us took the personal responsibility to protect ourselves and our families by getting vaccinated.
- Stop talking about restrictions and the unknown future ahead. If we focus on how bad things still are and how much worse they could get, we set Democrats up as failures unable to navigate us through this. When 99% of Americans can get vaccinated, we cause more harm than we prevent with voters by going into our third year talking about restrictions. And, if Democrats continue to hold a posture that prioritizes COVID precautions over learning how to live in a world where COVID exists, but does not dominate, they risk paying dearly for it in November.
A few points. There is no strong evidence that “shutdowns, masks, and lockdowns” saved lives which is perhaps why the memo backs away slightly from the claim with the words “meant to.” Good intentions, but ruined lives.
This memo is not epidemiology but politics, most strongly illustrated by the idea that polling should make the difference as to whether a pathogen is pandemic or endemic. The constant incantation of “vaccines” here has nothing to do with the known data: they have nowhere stopped infection or spread, a point which the memo obscures with the line about how they “minimize illness.” They minimize serious outcomes for some strains so long as they last.
From a policy point of view, there are two main features that stand out: Covid is here to stay and “most people in the US will eventually get COVID-19” (thereby hinting at the reality that vaccines are not effective in the way that Biden/Fauci/Walensky promised) and therefore the focus should be on protecting the vulnerable.
There is nothing new about this. It was always true! You can shout “Omicron” all day but it was also true with Alpha and Delta as well. The virus should have been treated rationally the entire time and policies that have wrecked public health should have been off the table from 2020. The memo writers did not cite the Great Barrington Declaration but they might as well have.
As for how the Democrats somehow prevented an economic freefall, the worst economic outcomes are very clearly in Democratic-controlled states that retained restrictions for nearly two years in some places, including keeping schools closed. There is a reason for the mass migration that this has inspired.
If we are looking for thriving economies, look to the states that never closed up or opened earliest: South Dakota, Florida, Texas, Georgia, and so on. So none of this is remotely true but, hey, this is politics, right?, so it doesn’t have to be true.
The real problem that the Democrats need to solve is revealed in this chart:
Now, let us consider the dramatic turnaround at the CDC that came out the very next day. The full PDF is embedded below.
Here are the talking points handed to the director. It’s not just about masking, which is being relaxed. The CDC says there needs to be a dramatic shift away from endless monitoring of cases that are overwhelmingly mild and instead focus only on actual sickness that lands people in the hospital and threatens life. We need to stop obsessing about cases and start looking mainly at “medically significant disease.” The focus should be on “protecting the most vulnerable.”
This makes all of us want to say, shout, scream: THANK YOU!
In order to justify this change, the CDC posts four sets of charts on Covid prevalence during episodes of the pandemic. The last chart illustrates the point that an exclusive focus on controlling the spread is utterly preposterous at this point. Under the old protocols, the whole country should be back in lockdown. It’s unimaginable what attempting this now would cause.
To be sure, all of this is enormously frustrating for those of us engaged in this battle for two years. Instead of focusing on getting sick people well, the CDC experimented with wild guidelines that imagined some kind of society-wide solution that seemed designed to crush the virus while vast amounts of social and economic activity were shut down by law. This necessitated a crushing of freedoms, including of travel, association, commerce, religion, and, eventually even speech.
The CDC nowhere admits this much less apologizes for it. Two years in, the CDC seems to have rediscovered the traditional practice of public health, and has justified this new wisdom based on changed conditions, while never even bothering to claim that its previous measures and guidelines achieved anything along the way.
We’ve seen a massive collapse in public health, economic vitality, and essential rights, while closing schools and wrecking education and so much more, all in the name of virus control, even as the evidence is now overwhelming that the entire enterprise was not only a distraction from what should have happened (therapeutics and protecting the vulnerable) but also an astonishing failure.
Why the change? It had to happen at some point. The entire machinery of lockdowns and mandates were destined to fail. As to the timing of the reversal, it’s hard to resist the speculation that it is entirely political. See the memo above.
Still, there is a worrisome aspect to the CDC’s announcement. They reserve the right to do it all over again. “We want to give people a break from things like mask-wearing, when these metrics are better, and then have the ability to reach for them again should things worsen,” she said.
No one should be satisfied with a politically motivated change in the messaging. We need fundamental regime change so make sure that nothing like this can ever happen again.
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal
-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)
“The more we talk about the threat of COVID and onerously restrict people’s lives because of it, the more we turn them against us and show them we’re out of touch with their daily realities.”
That is a startling confession for anyone willing to read it.
They’re so certain of their role as elites they talk about their own base as if they were the enemy.
Gold right there.
Only executions for crimes against humanity will address this.
Pure propaganda through and through. Here in rural Texas, 25% still mask up. And I am fine with their choice. I never did and never will. I have been telling my friends for at least since 9/11 what was really going on. Now they are starting to come out of their slumber and listen. We may be somewhat an echo chamber here, but sometimes it gives us fresh ideas and arguments to help wake those who listen with half an ear to the reality of the situation.
The war has begun.
Stay aware and be prepared.
2A
In rural Arkansas it is more like 1% wearing masks, plus feds and a few corpos.
In South Africa, you can get arrested for unmasking in public, and if in a shop, the shop can be closed down!
Interestingly, my first visit on The Burning Platform (was known as “SanDiego Guy” then) was in 2009, and it was during that space in time that any mention of 9-11 that failed to comport with the official gubmint narrative would get you banned from TBP in short order. So no, your friends weren’t the only one’s riding the short bus after 9-11. It’s tough acknowledging that you guzzled the KoolAid handed to you by the gubmint, because when you do you’re also compelled to admit that in all likelihood there were plenty other times that you accepted that swill previously. And that’s just as our overlords would have it, really, because the one’s easiest to con are also the one’s that can’t bear the thought that they’ve been had, and will therefore continue to state otherwise.
LOL. That map on the left showing yellow spots designating remaining ‘higher covid levels’ are the locations where the agenda was most ignored resulting in the least amount of economic destruction and least amount of vaxxed/vaxxed illness/deaths.
Reread knowing there was no CV, no variants or no test for ‘it’ let alone one valid statistic worldwide. Change my mind.
The didn’t-come-from-one-of-dozens-of-unaccountable-labs-we-promise GoF virus has to exist! Otherwise, what has DARPA and enlightened, billionaire eugenicists been funding and MSM-DeepState covering up?
If no Covid-911 doom, then why would landlord’s tolerate CDC suspending rent payments, local govts bankrupt small businesses and lose that tax revenue, Governors declare whose job is non-essential, the WHO halt normal, clinical preventative care and cancer screening, Dentists take the year off, Biden still demonize and fire mRNA skeptics, and FDA/Social Media ban even talking about affordable, effective, and off-patent treatments to replace “run, death is near” and hospital I.C.U. murder bounties?
Won’t you give WEF and Gates a 2nd chance to convince you with an exciting smallpox+AIDS release? How about if they get it right after last year’s proof-of-concept practice run with a 50% infection fatality rate from the bio-weapon and a hoped for 50% casualty rate from its mandated vaxx?
If we play along, maybe TPTB go easier with more provoked invasions, economic collapse, and food shortages? It is dangerous to get between nihilists and their prey.
The actions and mandates of public health organizations, Democrats, and Blue State authoritarians are a matter of historical public record.
What must occur now is to continue revealing Covid vaccine injuries, ailments, and deaths.
In other words, 2 + 2 must be made to equal 4 again.
I know a family whose 8-year-old kid recently died from a condition as a result of an unknown cause. Was the child vaxxed? I don’t know. But if hospital personnel, military whistleblower, insurance mortality rates and funeral industry revelations continue, people just might start asking questions.
what is the underlying motive for this over control process? It’s certainly not to contain or prevent disease. My guess is the imposition of more central government repression of the populace, but why?
Eugenics, de-population, through (ultimately) a digital ID (aka “mark of the beast”) for every man, woman, and child on the planet. Jesus gave us only one way to escape all of these things: the way is strait and narrow.