The Stirrings Of Conscience

Author: Quintus Curtius

Source: https://qcurtius.com/2022/10/08/the-stirrings-of-conscience/

The etymologists tell us that the word conscience is derived from the Latin conscire, meaning to know well, or to have an intimate knowledge of something.  This verb could be used in two contexts:  conscire alii (to know something along with someone else), and conscire sibi (to know something with oneself only).  Time and modern usage has given “conscience” the meaning of an internal conviction, a mental recognition of something.

Cicero comments on something that looks much like this inner mental recognition in his Tusculan Disputations when he says,

I do not know how it happens, but there is a kind of premonition of future ages embedded in our minds:  and this instinct is most powerful, and manifests itself most clearly, in men of the most sublime genius and noble spirit.  If this conviction were absent, who would be so delusional as to fritter away his life in unremitting labors and dangers?  [I.15]

 

What did he mean by this?  What is this “premonition of future ages” that he is talking about?  I believe Cicero is hinting at the presence of certain substratal currents flowing through our consciences, currents of eternal truth that are detectable by nearly all of us, but perhaps are only followed by the noblest and greatest among us.  The historian Polynaeus, in his Stratagems of War (VI.4), says that the Greek general and statesman Philopoemen introduced into his Achaean army the use of the long spear and shield, along with the helmet, coats of mail, and greaves.  Instead of having his men fight with javelins as lightly-armed troops, he made them stand “close and firm” during battle.

But perhaps just as importantly, he understood the psychological dimension of readiness and preparation.  He strenuously discouraged in his men all manifestation of luxury, extravagance, and vanity:  in clothing, in speech, in eating, and in every other sphere of personal conduct.  Philopoemen believed that these sorts of things were corrosive to one’s will and purpose.  “Military men,” he would say, “should be above everything that is not absolutely necessary.”  We should note that he was an extremely successful commander.

Along these same lines, Polynaeus notes (VI.6) that King Pyrrhus of Epirus, before he engaged in any way, always took certain steps against his potential adversary.  He would try to bring them to terms by letting them know of all the terrible consequences that would follow in the wake of hostilities with him.  He would also explain why it was in his opponent’s interest to reach an accommodation on favorable terms before violence was initiated.  Once the dogs of war were unleashed, he would say, there was no way to predict where things might go.  Now what these two examples—Philopoemen and Pyrrhus—have in common is that each of them had an inner conviction, a conscience, that propelled them to glory.  They were both willing to listen to that substratal stirring that agitated their minds, that premonition and instinct Cicero speaks about in the quote above.

This same force of conscience was what enabled the character of Capt. Gerd Wiesler to ascend to true greatness in the film The Lives of Others.  He could not abandon his humanity.  His surveillance of the writer Georg Dreyman awakened something in him that even he himself could not verbalize.  This internal knowledge, this blinding conviction, was what gave him the strength to carry out a selfless and sublime act of personal heroism that resonated through the years, without any recognition that he had done it until long after it was over.

But it seems that this kind of self-knowledge is not common.  The subconscious currents may flow through all of us, but not all of us heed them or act upon them.  I have known many clients over the years who experience all sorts of personal tragedies—divorces, bankruptcies, criminal cases—who never seem to do the kind of self-examination that might enable them to learn from their mistakes.  It is as if some blind wall encircles their consciousness.  They can never bring themselves to say, for example, “What was it that led me to this?” or “What is it about my personality, or my behavior, that is defective, and how may I correct this defect?”  If they do ask these questions, I am never told about it.  Instead, such people craft artful techniques to deflect responsibility for every misfortune on to someone else.  They are expert at casting aspersions on others, and impugning the characters of others.  This tactic can accomplish its purpose for a time, for as Gibbon says,

It is easy for faction and calumny to shed their poison on the administration of the best of princes, and to accuse even their virtues by artfully confounding them with those vices to which they bear the nearest affinity.  [Decline and Fall, Ch. VII]

 

Self-delusion and deflection work for a time:  but only for a time.  No matter how craftily we may sneak up on the mirror, our reflection always stares us squarely in the face.  Deep down, in the well of our souls, we know the differences between good and bad, and right and wrong.  What matters is whether we have the conviction to act on such knowledge.  The reason why so few do is because it is difficult to do so:  taking action in the service of one’s conscience involves shattering ingrained behavior patterns.  It involves an agonizing self-examination.  It may even entail a physical risk.  These are things that most men are simply unwilling to do.  But if a man values his long-term survival, he must do it.  The former Russian tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky was certainly no angel, but he did say something important after his release in 2013 from a lengthy prison term:

It was a strategic mistake of some Western institutions to think they could live without principles…This lack of principles has brought the West to the consequences it is experiencing now. This constant changing in saying what is good and what is bad has caused society to lose these principles for itself.

A conscience stirring beneath the mind’s mundane preoccupations is a call to action that we ignore at our own peril. We are told in Polynaeus (II.20) that when Demaratus sent his intelligence report about Xerxes’s army to the Spartans, he inscribed the information on a tablet that he then coated with wax. If it were intercepted, he believed no one would notice the writing underneath. But this ruse would have fooled no one. For no matter what the surface veneer may present to the world, writing that is true and indelible is always discernible to the viewer.

Click to visit the TBP Store for Great TBP Merchandise

10
Leave a Reply

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of
The Central Scrutinizer
The Central Scrutinizer

Sounds to me like someone’s conviction got conscience confused with temptation.

And what a load of crap to say Western society has no principles! They may not be the principles that any sane person would live by, but let’s not pretend they don’t exist.

hardscrabble farmer
hardscrabble farmer

You should elaborate.

CrashDavis
CrashDavis

western society worships:
1) unlimited welfare to reward government-sponsored banks and monopolies for losses they create with derivatives that are not worth the paper you wipe you ass with, and backed up by ‘collateral’ that does not exist and gets stuck on taxpayers, (and censoring anyone who notices how the Nazi government-monopoly elites censor us and kill us with death jabs)
2) pushing ‘ transgender’ men with all of of their male equipment into public girls bathrooms because they wear a wig and then hiring them to brainwash children into their pedophile sex cult at satanic government run schools
3) endless war to fund satanic MIC elites and then insisting on starting WW III by mass murdering UKR citizens in eastern UKR by Azov battalion Nazis that Soros and the Deep State staged a coup to put in power. (along with threats from pedo Lindsay Graham echoing his Epstein CIA blackmailers to “asassinate”Putin a G-20 world leader (who, although a Mafia Don, rejects all the evil 1.2.3, listed above).

Central Scrutinizer, you suck Satan’s knob and condemn me for not getting on my knees and sucking too?
F*ck You Assh*le.
You are one of the British Loyalist C*nts that need to be tagged first when the revs get going.

lamont cranston
lamont cranston

TCS- “joe’s Garage” was on SiriusXM the other day. You stated that the police gave Joe a donut and to attend church activities.

Sadly, XM didn’t play “Catholic Girls” next.

Defector
Defector

Thaks lamont for mentioning FZ again. His intervs on yt are well worth listening to.
Imagine what he would have said about the current situation if he was still alive.

Defector
Defector

Aunt Acid
Aunt Acid

It is usually an incisive read when someone is conversant in the Classics, and here pertinent and well presented.

Trying to find a pang of conscience here in the West is quite the challenge as it appears most individuals have had it vacuumed out via tel avision, work and skools leaving the husk of a human without sympathy, empathy, shame or guilt.

Should the realization of actions that have caused grief, pain and even death even arise it is just simple enough to post something banal and jejune on social media and wipe memory clean of having to think about anything that might cause unpleasantness.

Irrespective, some serious unpleasantness (moar than the CoVid-19(84) totalitarianism) is coming for most everyone on the blue marble and conscience will hopefully be fully expressed as people are confronted with privation, hunger, sickness, death and destruction.

CrashDavis
CrashDavis

aunt acid. i get your point (i think, maybe) but too much word salad and obfuscation and $1 million word pumping to make any sense.
Just spit it out. Say what you mean and cut out the B.S.
“blue marble” WTF!
enough already.

VOWG
VOWG

Don’t think too hard you might injure yourself.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Hmmm … self reflection, focus, and inner discipline.

All rare traits in this corrupt, epicurean age.

Discover more from The Burning Platform

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading