By Joe Guzzardi
Midway during the Major League Baseball owners’ lockout of its players, I promised myself that I was done. No more universal DH, ghost runner, launch angles, tender limbs, watered down Hall of Fame standards and – most of all – no more haggling between the billionaire owners, the multimillionaire players and meddlesome, anti-baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred. I pledged not to watch or listen to one-third of any inning of any 2022 game. Unlike more important self-help vows I’ve made, I stuck to my pledge – no small feat for a fan whose summers for the last seven decades have included daily baseball doses.
But another constant disappointment is the principal reason I’ve steadfastly refused to contribute one thin dime to baseball – its years-long miserly, shameful treatment of minor league players. Advocates for Minor Leaguers (AML) crunched numbers and found that the median annual salary for a minor league player today is $12,000. The federal poverty level is $12,800, and the 2021 average MLB franchise has a $1.9 billion value.
MLB team owners pay their minor hopefuls a standard $400 weekly salary at the Complex League level, $500 per week in Single-A, $600 per week in Double-A and $700 per week in Triple-A. Players are paid only during the regular season and playoffs, despite being required to perform year-round in off-the-field duties. Minor leaguers, whose numbers were slashed when Manfred mandated that 42 teams be eliminated, make an annual salary of between $4,800 and $15,400. Weekly payments for entry-level minor leaguers are less than what minimum-wage workers earn in some states for a 40-hour workweek.
Unlike major-leaguers, minor leaguers don’t draw checks until their first regular season game. Professional baseball is specifically exempted from federal labor protections. However, teams still are subject to state wage laws which owners routinely ignored. Instead, owners contended that players should be classified as short-term seasonal apprentices similar to farm laborers, a specious argument that a federal judge rejected.
Harry Marino, who played four minor league seasons, and is now AML executive director, said: “Guys struggle with housing, nutrition and making ends meet on a fundamental level. The system is outdated, exploitative and needs to change.” Last year, one viral AML video showed how nearly a dozen St. Louis Cardinals Double-A affiliate Springfield players were forced to sleep on the floor of a hotel banquet room while on the road.
In 2014, three retired minor league players filed a lawsuit which claimed violations of the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, as well as abuses of state minimum wage and overtime requirements. Eight years later, MLB agreed in court to pay minor leaguers $185 million to settle. An early guesstimate is that as many as 23,000 players could share the money with an average payment to each of $5,000 to $5,500. MLB grudgingly told the court that it approves of the settlement.
Garrett Broshuis, the players’ lead lawyer and a one-time minor league pitcher, called the settlement a “monumental step” toward “fair and just” compensation for the players. Broshuis continued: “I’ve seen first-hand the financial struggle players face while earning poverty-level wages – or no wages at all – in pursuit of their major league dream.”
The minor leaguers’ court win is a refreshing victory for the good guys against the stuffed-pockets, Scrooge McDuck-type tycoons content to let their prospects subsist on a bologna sandwich and sleep on the floor while they eat wagyu beef aboard chartered jets. Good baseball is everywhere – high school, college, Little and Pony Leagues, and the Independent League. Fans shouldn’t support the MLB tightwads, and can find better, more enjoyable baseball outlets close to home.
Joe Guzzardi is a Society for American Baseball Research and Internet Baseball Writers Association member. Contact him at [email protected].
It is my sincere desire to provide readers of this site with the best unbiased information available, and a forum where it can be discussed openly, as our Founders intended. But it is not easy nor inexpensive to do so, especially when those who wish to prevent us from making the truth known, attack us without mercy on all fronts on a daily basis. So each time you visit the site, I would ask that you consider the value that you receive and have received from The Burning Platform and the community of which you are a vital part. I can't do it all alone, and I need your help and support to keep it alive. Please consider contributing an amount commensurate to the value that you receive from this site and community, or even by becoming a sustaining supporter through periodic contributions. [Burning Platform LLC - PO Box 1520 Kulpsville, PA 19443] or Paypal
-----------------------------------------------------
To donate via Stripe, click here.
-----------------------------------------------------
Use promo code ILMF2, and save up to 66% on all MyPillow purchases. (The Burning Platform benefits when you use this promo code.)
The kids drafted and being payed millions on signing next to the kids being undrafted and having to struggle to survive cannot make for a great or even good atmosphere for the minor leagues. The cheapie owners are rolling in it at the expense of the kids trying to make it on less than minimum wage. It’s long past due to take away the anti trust exemption for pro baseball and also long past time for the team owners to pay for their own stadiums. Like politicians, they become rich at our [the taxpayers] expense.
Hmmmmm…..,I was in a very minor league band(loved it!)playing bars/parties ect.
We on our own put in a lot of money into gear ect.(which friends helped us move)to keep it on the road.
While I thought for a time till the end we were good(OK….great/excellent actually!)I never expected the music industry or other bands at top of the game to pay our way,either made it or didn’t!That’s life!
On a side note there are bands who have made it big who hear others following behind them and help them reach the big time,bless them!That though is a blessing/gift and not a given!
Minor league ball players/bands/any start in a profession are what gives one the chance to be major players in ones chosen field.
Earn the title!
You are full of shit! Teams make plenty of money that they can at least pay all players a reasonable wage. Not the same as a freelance band. Fuck those woke baseball owners that sponge on the tax payers. It’s easy to do a 5 minute calculation to determine they could all pay for their own stadiums with the money they take in.
I was in business 5 years- never asked anyone for a handout and always paid decent wages. Refuse to watch any professional sports- and college sports just as bad or worse exploiters.
Fine,perhaps require mlb to also fund/pay little league as they are the starting point of perhaps career players.
As for the stadiums I am against ALL forms of welfare,private or corporate.
goats,cats,tull-
getting worried about you jimmy,getting very worried about you–
While I worry for the world at large me own life just fine,well…..,excepting fools calling me “Jimmy”!
ouch–
at least give me some credit–
i did spell it w/a y instead of w/ie–
Tampa,have a good evening(they may be running short!).
Here we have cats and goats meeting for first time/while…….,listening to Tull!
i. e./lifes good!
they are cute but don’t get too attached in case you have to eat them–
billionaire owners, the multimillionaire players
I quit watching MLB after the second strike for that very reason and that was a very long time ago. I have since given up all professional sports for that same reason.
Why not feel the same way about any low paid employee? I’ve heard, so many times now, “people are paid what they’re worth to the business”. Or “they could always choose a different job/career/employer”.
a boy i grew up with & played ball with starting at age 8/9 wound up being drafted in the late 70s–
he was a catcher & had great defensive skills but he became a boozer & his work habits turned to crap,he only lasted about 3 years ,though he did get to aaa 4 awhile–
they were only paid about $600/month & could easily knock that downward thru fines if they were careless–
$25 for their socks not being correct,$25 for not wearing shower slippers,etc.–
one off season he & a couple of other players lived in a beat up trailer that was on about a 1 acre lot in our old neighborhood–we used to have hardcore drinking parties there–
of the other 2 guys,one flamed out but the other made it to the bigs–he wasn’t even a star but man did he have the bucks–
he later became a coach but i’ve lost track & don’t know if he is still involved w/mlb–
Thanks Mr. Guzzardi, I’m right there with you. The last time I watched Pro or NCAA sports was in the last century. Like you I was sick of the BS. Millionaire players, arguing with billionaire owners and promoters, and telling me how problematic the fans are for not understanding their pitiful situation.
Now we have more of the same coming from millionaire actors, directors, and musicians telling me what a shit I am for NOT going along with their latest foolish idea (insert idiotic cause here_________).
Once again, for the most part, I quit watching.
See, another problem is playuhs who be tryin’ to get in shape so’s they might be able to play in a league.
That requires running.
…to lose weight, etc.
This man DooWayne ran into further obstacles, while out jogging with no shirt on, in his quest to be a member of the MLB.
Well, because, he ran afoul of the Baltimore PD and courts.
Sound up.
Sometimes, you just have to laugh.
Yes, yes you do….LMAO….
Not sure who dv’d you, bud, but no worries.
That clip was scripted, for sure, so fat Dwayne is performing comedy for a videographer who has splicing skills and a YT account, but, whatever.
Twas another one posted on Chief Nose Wetters blog.
Be well, friend.
When I saw the Houston Astros pitchers mound emblazoned with the BLM logo was the moment I hated MLB.
Yes. I had previously been mostly separated from “sports,” maintained a casual interest just for social interaction purposes, but the BLM, etc. displays were the final nail.
What lockout?
But apparently they have plenty of money for this….
20 MLB Teams ‘Promote or Fund’ Groups that Perform Child Sex Change Operations
The magazine reviewed the causes and organizations to which these teams are handing out millions of dollars in donations and found that many support sex-change surgery, hormone treatments, and other dangerous procedures for “transitioning” teens and pre-teens.
National Review found that almost every team in the league “promote or fund groups that encourage or provide sex-change procedures and gender-transition hormone treatment for minors as young as 12.
https://www.breitbart.com/sports/2022/08/31/report-20-mlb-teams-promote-fund-groups-perform-child-sex-change-operations/